Mottet Auselo N, Bons-Rosset F, Pellae-Cosset B, Costa P, Schwartz Y, Louis J F, Navratil H
Service d'urologie-andrologie, CHU Gaston-Doumergue, Nîmes.
Bull Cancer. 1995 Mar;82(3):181-8.
Polychemotherapy appears to increase survival moderately but at a cost of severe toxicity, mainly due to cisplatin. New platinum salts (chiefly carboplatin) have therefore been developed. This review on the use of carboplatin in advanced-stage urothelial tumours was undertaken to find the actual place of carboplatin in the treatment of these tumours, and to describe its best use in polychemotherapy. In 322 patients, carboplatin alone gave 12.9% objective responses (OR), 2.5% complete responses (CR) and 10.4% partial response (PR). Many polychemotherapy protocols were used, most frequently carboplatin/methotrexate/vinblastin. The results were OR: 63%, CR: 19%, PR: 44% among 146 patients. These results confirm the relative efficiency of carboplatin on urothelial tumours, particularly when used in combination. Because of the lack of prospective studies and the wide disparity in the doses and in the dose adjustment, no comparison can be made with cisplatin. Carboplatin has virtually no renal toxicity at the usual doses, and does not require hyperhydratation. The pharmacokinetic behaviour of the two platinum salts is highly different, as carboplatin does not undergo tubular metabolism. The efficiency and tolerance of carboplatin used to be optimised by adapting the dose to the glomerular filtration rate, as was shown for germ cell tumours. In conclusion, these considerations fully warrant further clinical trials of carboplatin.
多药化疗似乎能适度提高生存率,但代价是严重毒性,主要是顺铂所致。因此,人们研发了新的铂盐(主要是卡铂)。开展此次关于卡铂在晚期尿路上皮肿瘤中应用的综述,旨在明确卡铂在这些肿瘤治疗中的实际地位,并描述其在多药化疗中的最佳应用方式。在322例患者中,单独使用卡铂的客观缓解率(OR)为12.9%,完全缓解率(CR)为2.5%,部分缓解率(PR)为10.4%。使用了多种多药化疗方案,最常用的是卡铂/甲氨蝶呤/长春碱。在146例患者中,结果为OR:63%,CR:19%,PR:44%。这些结果证实了卡铂对尿路上皮肿瘤的相对疗效,尤其是联合使用时。由于缺乏前瞻性研究以及剂量和剂量调整存在很大差异,无法与顺铂进行比较。卡铂在常用剂量下几乎没有肾毒性,也不需要水化。两种铂盐的药代动力学行为差异很大,因为卡铂不经过肾小管代谢。正如在生殖细胞肿瘤中所显示的那样,通过根据肾小球滤过率调整剂量可优化卡铂的疗效和耐受性。总之,这些考量完全有必要对卡铂开展进一步的临床试验。