A new "closed" in situ vein bypass technique results in a reduced wound complication rate.

OBJECTIVES

This prospective randomised multicentre trial was conducted to test whether a new "closed" technique for in situ vein bypass would result in a lower frequency of wound complications, without negative effects on patency rates and without an intolerable increase in residual arteriovenous fistulae compared to the conventional "open" technique.

METHODS

We have developed a new "closed" technique using a co-axial catheter embolisation system for intra-operative coil embolisation of side branches, in order to avoid long incisions.

PATIENTS

In four centres and 95 patients, 97 in situ bypasses were performed: 47 "closed" and 50 "open". Randomisation was stratified for below knee femoropopliteal bypasses (60) and femorocrural bypasses (37). Indications were disabling intermittent claudication (29), restpain (26) or ulcers and/or necrosis (42).

RESULTS

Postoperative mortality was 2% (one in the "closed", one in the "open" group). A total number of 16 (34%) wound complications (grade 1, 2 and 3) occurred in the closed group compared to 36 (72%) in the open group (p < 0.05). Deep wound complications (grade 2) occurred in six patients (13%) of the "closed" group, compared to 15 (30%) in the "open" group. In both groups, three patients (6%) developed deep wound complications including the bypass area (grade 3). In the "closed" group, 20 patients needed additional treatment for arteriovenous fistulae, compared to four in the "open" group. One-year patency rates did not show a statistically significant difference: primary patency rates were 65% and 61% and secondary patency rates were 86% and 76% respectively for the "closed" and "open" group.

CONCLUSION

These results indicate that a "closed" technique reduces wound complication rate, without negative effects on the short term patency rates. The "closed" technique results in an increased number of postoperative treatments for residual arteriovenous fistulae.