Phibbs R H
Department of Pediatrics, University of California, San Francisco, USA.
J Perinat Med. 1995;23(1-2):127-31. doi: 10.1515/jpme.1995.23.1-2.127.
It has been well established that erythropoietin (EPO) in the dosage range of 500 units/kilo/week and perhaps slightly lower doses will produce a brisk reticulocyte response in infants with anemia of prematurity. Controlled clinical trials to demonstrate that this therapy can result in significant reductions in transfusion in these babies face several complex issues of experimental design. 1. Should the study population be relatively bigger, healthier babies (< 1500 grams birth weight, not on ventilatory support) who have lower transfusion requirements, or smaller sicker infants (< 1250 grams birth weight and on ventilators) who have higher transfusion requirements? These infants will need adequate nutrition and liberal supplementation with iron if they are to respond adequately, but the sicker smaller infants will take longer to meet these nutritional goals. 2. Timing is important because spontaneous recovery occurs at about 35 to 36 weeks of corrected gestational age, so to be effective, therapy must start before 33 weeks of gestational age and preferably earlier than that. 3. Since the end point is transfusion, the criteria used for transfusions become a critical issue. If liberal transfusion criteria are used, the study will be doubly biased in favor of EPO efficacy. There will be an increased number of transfusion events in the control population and spontaneous recovery from the anemia of prematurity will be overly suppressed in the control population. It's likely that the current transfusion criteria are too liberal thus introducing these biases to experimental design.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
已经明确的是,对于早产贫血婴儿,每周每公斤500单位剂量的促红细胞生成素(EPO)以及可能稍低剂量会产生快速的网织红细胞反应。进行对照临床试验以证明这种疗法能显著减少这些婴儿的输血次数面临几个实验设计方面的复杂问题。1. 研究人群应该是输血需求较低、相对较大且健康的婴儿(出生体重<1500克,无需通气支持),还是输血需求较高、更小且患病的婴儿(出生体重<1250克且使用呼吸机)?如果这些婴儿要充分反应,他们需要充足的营养和大量的铁补充,但更小且患病的婴儿达到这些营养目标所需时间更长。2. 时机很重要,因为在矫正胎龄约35至36周时会出现自发恢复,所以要有效,治疗必须在胎龄33周之前开始,最好更早。3. 由于终点是输血,用于输血的标准就成了关键问题。如果使用宽松的输血标准,该研究将在有利于EPO疗效方面产生双重偏差。对照组的输血事件数量会增加,并且对照组中早产贫血的自发恢复会被过度抑制。目前的输血标准可能过于宽松,从而给实验设计带来这些偏差。(摘要截选至250字)