Shannon I L, Buchanan W E, Mahan C J
J Public Health Dent. 1976 Summer;36(3):201-6. doi: 10.1111/j.1752-7325.1976.tb02597.x.
Two-minute topical applications with four different fluoride compounds, acidulated phosphate fluoride, sodium fluoride, sodium monofluorophosphate and stannous fluoride, were evaluated for ability to reduce the acide solubility of human root surfaces in vitro. Each fluoride was in aqueous solution with the fluoride level adjusted to 1.23 percent and the pH native. Rectangular windows were prepared on root surfaces and control versus test differences were invariably studied within teeth and not between teeth. Sodium fluoride and sodium monofluorophosphate solutions reduced root surface solubility by approximately 30 percent while acidulated phosphate fluoride and stannous fluoride were more than 2.5 times more effective, the solubility reduction exceeding 80 percent. Root surfaces thus are similar to enamel in their reactions to topically applied fluorides. Based upon these results the clinician should choose between acidulated phosphate fluoride and stannous fluoride when making the choice of a single treatment compound for office application.
评估了用四种不同的氟化物(酸化磷酸氟、氟化钠、单氟磷酸钠和氟化亚锡)进行两分钟局部应用,以降低人牙根表面在体外酸溶解性的能力。每种氟化物均处于水溶液中,氟含量调整为1.23%,pH值为天然值。在牙根表面制备矩形窗口,对照组与测试组之间的差异始终在牙齿内部而非牙齿之间进行研究。氟化钠和单氟磷酸钠溶液使牙根表面溶解度降低约30%,而酸化磷酸氟和氟化亚锡的效果则高出2.5倍以上,溶解度降低超过80%。因此,牙根表面对局部应用氟化物的反应与牙釉质相似。基于这些结果,临床医生在选择用于诊所应用的单一治疗化合物时,应在酸化磷酸氟和氟化亚锡之间做出选择。