Korvick D L, Johnson A L, Schaeffer D J
Department of Laboratory Animal Resources, University of Texas Health Science Center, San Antonio 78284-7859.
J Am Vet Med Assoc. 1994 Nov 1;205(9):1318-24.
To characterize veterinary surgeons' preferences in diagnostic, surgical, and postoperative management of cranial cruciate ligament ruptures in dogs, 175 surgeons, including American College of Veterinary Surgeons diplomates, surgery specialty-practice veterinarians, university surgeons, and surgery residents, were surveyed. Their experience with stifle surgery was evenly distributed from 1 to > 21 years. Approximately 70% (118/175) of surgeons treated 3 to 9 dogs with cranial cruciate ligament rupture each month. In diagnosis, 98% (172/175) of the surgeons used a cranial drawer test with the stifle joint at 140 degrees of flexion. Stifle radiography was performed by 53% (93/175) of surgeons for acute and by 81% (141/175) of surgeons for chronic cases. In repair of cranial cruciate ligament ruptures, 32% (56/175) of surgeons did not use intra-articular procedures, whereas 8% (14/175) of surgeons did not use extra-articular procedures. Surgical preferences depended on dog size (P < 0.05). For small dogs (ie, < 11 kg), 80% (140/175) of surgeons used extra-articular methods, and 14% (24/175) used intra-articular methods. For medium dogs (ie, 11 to 29 kg), 52% (91/175) of surgeons used extra-articular and 43% (75/175) used intra-articular methods. For large dogs (ie, > 29 kg), surgeons' preferences depended on the injury's duration (P < 0.05). For large dogs with acute injuries, 39% (68/175) preferred extra-articular and 55% (96/175) preferred intra-articular, whereas in chronic cases, 52% (91/175) preferred extra-articular and 42% (73/175) preferred intra-articular. The most common extra-articular method was placement of a suture from the lateral fabella to a hole drilled in the tibial tuberosity.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
为了明确兽医在犬颅交叉韧带断裂的诊断、手术及术后管理方面的偏好,研究人员对175名兽医进行了调查,其中包括美国兽医外科学院的专科医师、外科专科执业兽医、大学兽医以及外科住院医师。他们进行 stifle 手术的经验从1年到超过21年不等,分布较为均匀。大约70%(118/175)的兽医每月治疗3至9只患有颅交叉韧带断裂的犬。在诊断方面,98%(172/175)的兽医在 stifle 关节屈曲140度时进行颅抽屉试验。53%(93/175)的兽医对急性病例进行 stifle 关节造影,81%(141/175)的兽医对慢性病例进行造影。在颅交叉韧带断裂的修复中,32%(56/175)的兽医不采用关节内手术,而8%(14/175)的兽医不采用关节外手术。手术偏好取决于犬的体型(P < 0.05)。对于小型犬(即<11 kg),80%(140/175)的兽医采用关节外方法,14%(24/175)采用关节内方法。对于中型犬(即11至29 kg),52%(91/175)的兽医采用关节外方法,43%(75/175)采用关节内方法。对于大型犬(即>29 kg),兽医的偏好取决于损伤的持续时间(P < 0.05)。对于急性损伤的大型犬,39%(68/175)更喜欢关节外手术,55%(96/175)更喜欢关节内手术;而在慢性病例中,52%(91/175)更喜欢关节外手术,42%(73/175)更喜欢关节内手术。最常见的关节外方法是从外侧腓肠豆向胫骨结节上钻的孔放置缝线。(摘要截选至250字)