Ferriere R, Michod R E
Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, University of Arizona, Tucson, 85721, USA.
Proc Biol Sci. 1995 Jan 23;259(1354):77-83. doi: 10.1098/rspb.1995.0012.
Explaining the emergence of cooperative behaviours in a selfish world remains a major challenge for sociobiology. The iterated prisoner's dilemma offers a well-studied metaphor with which to explore theoretically the evolution of cooperation by reciprocation. Our current understanding is that 'tit-for-tat' should be the very first step (if not the aim) of evolution towards cooperation, but that mobility of the players in space seems to raise a devastating obstacle to the spread of tit-for-tat, by allowing egoists to exploit cooperation and escape retaliation. The second point is based on models that represent mobility only implicitly (in terms of travelling costs) and assume random interactions. Here we develop a more explicit theory of spatial iterated games: individual mobility is represented in terms of a diffusion process and interactions--defined locally--are inherently non-random. Our model reveals the existence of critical levels of individual mobility allowing for the evolution of cooperation. In fact, tit-for-tat can spread and take over among mobile players even when originating from extreme rarity. The dynamics of invasion of tit-for-tat develop as a travelling wave which propagates the cooperative strategy through space. Significant mobility is required to make the pioneering moves of cooperators towards the front of invasion less hazardous; it also contributes to neutralizing those defectors who may intrude the core of a cluster of cooperative players.
在一个自私的世界中解释合作行为的出现仍然是社会生物学面临的一项重大挑战。重复囚徒困境提供了一个经过充分研究的隐喻,用以从理论上探索通过互惠实现合作的进化过程。我们目前的理解是,“以牙还牙”策略应该是向合作进化的第一步(如果不是目标的话),但参与者在空间中的移动性似乎给“以牙还牙”策略的传播带来了一个毁灭性的障碍,因为这使得利己主义者能够利用合作并逃避报复。第二点是基于一些模型,这些模型只是隐含地表示移动性(根据旅行成本)并假设随机互动。在这里,我们发展了一种更明确的空间重复博弈理论:个体移动性用扩散过程来表示,并且在局部定义的互动本质上是非随机的。我们的模型揭示了存在允许合作进化的个体移动性临界水平。事实上,即使“以牙还牙”策略最初极为罕见,它也能在移动参与者中传播并占据主导地位。“以牙还牙”策略的入侵动态以行波的形式发展,这种行波将合作策略传播到整个空间。需要显著的移动性才能使合作者向入侵前沿的开拓性行动风险降低;它也有助于抵消那些可能侵入合作参与者群体核心的背叛者的影响。