Steinbaum S S, Uretzky I D, McAdams H P, Torrington K G, Cohen A J
Department of Thoracic Surgery, Walter Reed Army Medical Center, Washington, DC., USA.
Chest. 1995 Apr;107(4):1058-61. doi: 10.1378/chest.107.4.1058.
We sought to evaluate the effect of new diagnostic modalities on patients explored surgically for inoperable lung cancer. From July 1983 to February 1992, 335 patients underwent thoracotomy for lung cancer. Thirty-three of the 35 patients with nonresectable disease had sufficient data for analysis and underwent chest radiography (CXR), CT scan, and bronchoscopy. The study was terminated when video-assisted thoracoscopy (VAT) was introduced at the institution. Causes of nonresectability included significant N2 disease not diagnosed preoperatively (n = 11), tumor invasion of contiguous mediastinal structures (n = 8), and insufficient pulmonary function (n = 4). Four patients were left with unresected disease because of thoracic metastasis. Two patients had technically unresectable disease; three patients were explored surgically because diagnoses could be obtained by no other means. One patient was found to have small cell cancer. Data analysis demonstrated that 19 of 33 thoracotomies could potentially have been avoided or resulted in resection with current techniques. Refinement of imaging criteria, a judicious surgical approach to N2 disease, and VAT may significantly reduce thoracotomies for nonresectable lung cancer.
我们试图评估新的诊断方法对因无法手术切除的肺癌而接受手术探查的患者的影响。从1983年7月至1992年2月,335例患者因肺癌接受了开胸手术。35例不可切除疾病患者中的33例有足够的数据进行分析,并接受了胸部X线摄影(CXR)、CT扫描和支气管镜检查。当该机构引入电视辅助胸腔镜检查(VAT)时,研究终止。不可切除的原因包括术前未诊断出的显著N2疾病(n = 11)、肿瘤侵犯相邻纵隔结构(n = 8)和肺功能不足(n = 4)。4例患者因胸内转移而未切除病灶。2例患者存在技术上不可切除的疾病;3例患者接受了手术探查,因为无法通过其他方法获得诊断。1例患者被发现患有小细胞癌。数据分析表明,采用当前技术,33例开胸手术中的19例可能可以避免或实现切除。完善影像学标准、对N2疾病采取明智的手术方法以及电视辅助胸腔镜检查可能会显著减少因不可切除肺癌而进行的开胸手术。