Paran E, Holzberg G, Mazor M, Zmora E, Insler V
Hypertension Unit, Soroka University Medical Center, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Beer Sheva, Israel.
Int J Clin Pharmacol Ther. 1995 Feb;33(2):119-23.
Fifty-one women with pregnancy-induced hypertension (PIH) were randomly allocated to one of three treatment groups: A: hydralazine (13); B: hydralazine and propranolol (17); and C: hydralazine and pindolol (19). All women fulfilled the pretreatment criteria and were of similar age, numbers of previous pregnancies and had systolic blood pressure (SBP) of between 140 and 160 mmHg and diastolic blood pressure (DBP) of between 95 and 110 mmHg. Hypertension was treated equally well by all three regimens (mean SBP was 133.6, 130 and 134 mmHg, respectively). Heart rate was significantly higher than baseline in group A and lower in groups B and C, as is to be expected with beta-blocker treatment. Side-effects were more frequent in group A than in groups B and C, 62% of the patients on hydralazine monotherapy complained of palpitations compared to 35% on combination treatment. Fetal outcome differed in the various groups. Birth weight was significantly lower in group B, where regimen included propranolol, compared to that of group C, for whom the regimen included pindolol (3,044.7 +/- 443.8 and 2,709.6 +/- 485.5 gm, p < 0.05). Mean blood glucose of the newborns were similar in groups A and C (76.5 +/- 16.5 and 78.6 +/- 15 gm%) and significantly lower in group B (62.6 +/- 14 gm%, p < 0.02). In conclusion, blood pressure was equally well treated in all three treatment groups. However, more maternal side-effects occurred in group A, the group treated with hydralazine monotherapy, while propranolol in combination with hydrazaline (group B) had some negative effects on fetal development which did not occur in pindolol/hydrazaline combination.
51名妊娠高血压综合征(PIH)女性被随机分配到三个治疗组之一:A组:肼屈嗪(13例);B组:肼屈嗪和普萘洛尔(17例);C组:肼屈嗪和吲哚洛尔(19例)。所有女性均符合预处理标准,年龄、既往妊娠次数相似,收缩压(SBP)在140至160 mmHg之间,舒张压(DBP)在95至110 mmHg之间。三种治疗方案对高血压的治疗效果相同(平均SBP分别为133.6、130和134 mmHg)。如预期的β受体阻滞剂治疗效果一样,A组心率显著高于基线水平,B组和C组心率较低。A组的副作用比B组和C组更频繁,接受肼屈嗪单药治疗的患者中有62%抱怨有心悸,而联合治疗组为35%。不同组的胎儿结局有所不同。与C组(方案包括吲哚洛尔)相比,B组(方案包括普萘洛尔)的出生体重显著更低(分别为3044.7±443.8克和2709.6±485.5克,p<0.05)。A组和C组新生儿的平均血糖相似(分别为76.5±16.5和78.6±15克%),B组显著更低(62.6±14克%,p<0.02)。总之,三个治疗组对血压的治疗效果相同。然而,A组(接受肼屈嗪单药治疗的组)出现了更多的母体副作用,而普萘洛尔与肼屈嗪联合使用(B组)对胎儿发育有一些负面影响,而吲哚洛尔/肼屈嗪联合使用则未出现这种情况。