Smith D, Pearce L, Pringle M, Caplan R
Breakfree Service for Adult Survivors, Lincoln.
BMJ. 1995 May 6;310(6988):1175-8. doi: 10.1136/bmj.310.6988.1175.
To evaluate a pilot service offering therapy specifically to adults with a history of child sexual abuse.
Questionnaire survey.
Specialised therapy unit, Breakfree, which offers care, therapy, and support.
116 clients presenting to the service who were offered therapy.
Scores from three psychological questionnaires--the social activities and distress scale, the general health questionnaire, and the delusions, symptoms, and states inventory--and from questionnaires about the clients' abuse, previous use of health services, and opinion of the Breakfree service.
Clients had received previous help from health services and other agencies without apparent effect; they were highly distressed according to their psychological scores; and they were very frequent users of the health services. The clients showed significant improvement in their psychological scores (Wilcoxon's matched pairs signed ranks test): social activities and distress scale, z = -3.3, P = 0.001; general health questionnaire, z = -5.8, P < 0.00001; delusions, symptoms, and states inventory, z = -4.8, P < 0.00001). This was most pronounced for those who had completed therapy by the end of the study. Whereas 82/88 clients had a score for the general health questionnaire that indicated clinical distress at the start, only 28/58 did so at the end of the study (only 17/35 among those who had finished therapy).
This group of adults with a history of child sexual abuse were highly disturbed and previous high users of the health service. The specialist service Breakfree was effective in the short term and, if the benefits are sustained, would yield a net cost saving to the health service.
评估一项专门为有儿童性虐待史的成年人提供治疗的试点服务。
问卷调查。
专门的治疗机构Breakfree,提供护理、治疗和支持。
116名前来该服务机构接受治疗的客户。
来自三份心理问卷(社交活动与痛苦量表、一般健康问卷、妄想、症状及状态量表)的得分,以及关于客户受虐待情况、以前使用医疗服务的情况和对Breakfree服务看法的问卷得分。
客户此前曾从医疗服务机构和其他机构获得帮助,但未见明显效果;根据心理得分,他们极度痛苦;并且他们是医疗服务的频繁使用者。客户的心理得分有显著改善(威尔科克森配对符号秩检验):社交活动与痛苦量表,z = -3.3,P = 0.001;一般健康问卷,z = -5.8,P < 0.00001;妄想、症状及状态量表,z = -4.8,P < 0.00001)。对于那些在研究结束时完成治疗的人来说,这种改善最为明显。在研究开始时,82/88名客户的一般健康问卷得分表明存在临床痛苦,而在研究结束时,只有28/58名客户如此(在完成治疗的人中,只有17/35名)。
这组有儿童性虐待史的成年人受到严重困扰,以前是医疗服务的高使用者。专门的Breakfree服务在短期内是有效的,如果其益处能够持续,将为医疗服务节省净成本。