van Steenberghe D, Rosenberg D, Naert I E, Van den Bossche L, Nys M
Catholic University of Leuven, Faculty of Medicine, Department of Periodontology (Laboratory of Oral Physiology), Belgium.
J Periodontol. 1995 Mar;66(3):165-70. doi: 10.1902/jop.1995.66.3.165.
The reproducibility of an electronic device for the assessment of periodontal tissues damping characteristics was judged by evaluating the inter-examiner, inter-device and day to day variations of the measurements (PTVs). Nine young periodontally healthy volunteers were examined by two examiners (EX-1 and EX-2) and two devices (D-1 and D-2) in the following sequence: EX-1 D-1, EX-2 D-1, EX-1 D-2, and EX-2 D-2. PTVs were obtained at 5 different occasions during the same day. In some instances examiner 2 measured higher scores than examiner 1 with both devices. This difference was statistically significant (P = 0.05), if the total of 900 measurements was considered. The measurements of device 2 were approximately 0.5 PTV units higher, also reaching a statistical significance (P = 0.05). This difference is of limited clinical significance. The day to day variation was evaluated by comparing the scores obtained at 8 a.m. with the ones at the four other periods. The lowest scores were measured at 8 a.m. Only the 11 a.m. and the 2 p.m. measurements differed significantly. The effect of hormonal changes during the menstrual cycle and of smoking habits on PTVs were also evaluated. Ten female periodontally healthy volunteers were examined three times a week, during a period of two menstrual cycles. No significant PTV changes were found during the menstrual cycle. The effect of the smoking habit on PTVs was tested on 23 periodontally healthy patients.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
通过评估检查者之间、设备之间以及测量值(牙周组织振动特性值,PTV)的每日变化,来判断一种用于评估牙周组织振动特性的电子设备的可重复性。九名牙周健康的年轻志愿者由两名检查者(EX-1和EX-2)和两台设备(D-1和D-2)按照以下顺序进行检查:EX-1使用D-1、EX-2使用D-1、EX-1使用D-2、EX-2使用D-2。在同一天的5个不同时间点获取PTV值。在某些情况下,检查者2使用两台设备测得的分数均高于检查者1。如果将总共900次测量值考虑在内,这种差异具有统计学意义(P = 0.05)。设备2的测量值大约高0.5个PTV单位,同样具有统计学意义(P = 0.05)。这种差异的临床意义有限。通过比较上午8点与其他四个时间段获得的分数来评估每日变化。上午8点测得的分数最低。只有上午11点和下午2点的测量值有显著差异。还评估了月经周期中的激素变化和吸烟习惯对PTV值的影响。十名牙周健康的女性志愿者在两个月经周期内每周接受三次检查。在月经周期中未发现PTV值有显著变化。对23名牙周健康的患者测试了吸烟习惯对PTV值的影响。(摘要截断于250字)