Phipps K
Oregon Health Sciences University, USA.
J Public Health Dent. 1995 Winter;55(1):53-6. doi: 10.1111/j.1752-7325.1995.tb02331.x.
This paper reviews some of the studies related to the effect of fluoride on the skeletal system of humans and outlines the knowns and unknowns of fluoride and bone health. Current research indicates that, in large enough doses, fluoride stimulates bone formation by osteoblastic stimulation, increases bone formation earlier and to a larger extent in trabecular bone compared to cortical bone, and increases spinal bone density. There is controversy, however, concerning the efficacy of fluoride as a therapeutic agent in the treatment of osteoporosis. Some clinical studies have found a reduction in vertebral fracture rates while others have not. To date, only ecologic studies have been conducted on the association between water fluoridation and hip fractures. The inability of ecologic studies to control for confounding variables makes their interpretation difficult. Based on the literature presented, it is concluded that there are more unknowns than knowns in terms of fluoride's effect on bone, osteoporosis, and fractures. One of the major unknowns in the relationship between fluoride and bone health is dose and duration. Two studies are underway that attempt to describe the dose-response relationship between waterborne fluoride and osteoporosis. These studies will be completed in the near future and their results, while providing new insight into fluoride's effects on bone, will by no means answer all the questions raised on this issue.
本文回顾了一些与氟化物对人体骨骼系统影响相关的研究,并概述了氟化物与骨骼健康方面已知和未知的情况。当前研究表明,在足够大的剂量下,氟化物通过刺激成骨细胞来促进骨形成,与皮质骨相比,在小梁骨中更早且更大程度地增加骨形成,并增加脊柱骨密度。然而,关于氟化物作为治疗骨质疏松症的治疗剂的疗效存在争议。一些临床研究发现椎体骨折率有所降低,而另一些研究则未发现。迄今为止,仅针对水氟化与髋部骨折之间的关联进行了生态学研究。生态学研究无法控制混杂变量,这使得对其结果的解读变得困难。根据所呈现的文献得出结论,就氟化物对骨骼、骨质疏松症和骨折的影响而言,未知的情况比已知的更多。氟化物与骨骼健康关系中的一个主要未知因素是剂量和持续时间。目前有两项研究正在进行,试图描述水中氟化物与骨质疏松症之间的剂量反应关系。这些研究将在不久的将来完成,其结果虽然会为氟化物对骨骼的影响提供新的见解,但绝不能回答关于这个问题提出的所有问题。