Marciello M A, Herbison G J, Ditunno J F, Marino R J, Cohen M E
Department of Rehabilitation Medicine, Jefferson Medical College, Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA.
J Neurotrauma. 1995 Feb;12(1):99-106. doi: 10.1089/neu.1995.12.99.
The purpose of this study was to show that independence of self care activities of motor complete quadriplegic patients related better to the force of contraction of the wrist extensor (WE) muscles measured by a hand held myometer than to the manual muscle test (MMT) for grades 3 to 5. The patients (n = 24), identified by having unilaterally or bilaterally functional WE muscle (MMT > or = 3/5) with bilateral elbow extensor (EE) muscles < 3/5, were evaluated at 2 to 6 months after injury for four feeding activities utilizing the Quadriplegia Index of Function (QIF). We found 54% were independent drinking from a cup, 58% using a spoon or fork, 13% cutting food, and 23% pouring liquids. Comparisons were made between right, left, and bilateral mean myometry scores and median MMT scores for each of the QIF activities. The independent group of patients had myometry scores 54 to 140% greater (p < 0.05) than those patients dependent in the self care activity except when the right or left WE myometric score was analyzed for cutting food (p = 0.1). MMT comparisons showed no significant median score differences in any activity performed. There were no patients with only one WE muscle > or = 3/5 (n = 9) who were able to cut food or pour liquids independently. In conclusion, myometry appeared to be a better indicator than the MMT for some self care activities evaluated utilizing the Quadriplegia Index of Function.
本研究的目的是表明,对于运动完全性四肢瘫痪患者,其自理活动的独立性与通过手持肌动计测量的腕伸肌(WE)肌肉收缩力的相关性,要比与3至5级的徒手肌力测试(MMT)的相关性更好。这些患者(n = 24)的特征为单侧或双侧功能性WE肌肉(MMT>或= 3/5),双侧肘伸肌(EE)肌肉<3/5,在受伤后2至6个月,使用四肢瘫痪功能指数(QIF)对四项进食活动进行评估。我们发现,54%的患者能够独立用杯子喝水,58%的患者能够独立使用勺子或叉子,13%的患者能够独立切割食物,23%的患者能够独立倒液体。对每项QIF活动的右侧、左侧和双侧平均肌动计评分与MMT中位数评分进行了比较。除了在分析切割食物的右侧或左侧WE肌动计评分时(p = 0.1),自理活动独立的患者组的肌动计评分比自理活动依赖的患者组高54%至140%(p < 0.05)。MMT比较显示,在进行的任何活动中,中位数评分均无显著差异。没有仅一侧WE肌肉>或= 3/5的患者(n = 9)能够独立切割食物或倒液体。总之,对于使用四肢瘫痪功能指数评估的某些自理活动,肌动计似乎比MMT是更好的指标。