Hochman J S, Boland J, Sleeper L A, Porway M, Brinker J, Col J, Jacobs A, Slater J, Miller D, Wasserman H
Division of Cardiology, St Luke's/Roosevelt Hospital Center, New York, NY 10025.
Circulation. 1995 Feb 1;91(3):873-81. doi: 10.1161/01.cir.91.3.873.
Cardiogenic shock remains the leading cause of death of patients hospitalized with acute myocardial infarction (MI). This study was conducted to examine (1) the current spectrum of cardiogenic shock, (2) the proportion of patients who are potential candidates for a trial of early revascularization, and (3) the apparent impact of early revascularization on mortality.
Nineteen participating centers in the United States and Belgium prospectively registered all patients diagnosed with cardiogenic shock. Two hundred fifty-one patients were registered. The mean age was 67.5 +/- 11.7 years, and 43% were women. Acute mitral regurgitation or ventricular septal rupture was the cause of shock in 8%. Concurrent conditions contributing to the development of shock were noted in 5%, and 2% had isolated right ventricular shock. Among the remaining 214 patients, nonspecific findings on the ECG associated with "nontransmural" MI were seen in 14%. The median time to shock diagnosis after MI was 8 hours. The overall in-hospital mortality was 66%. Patients clinically selected to undergo cardiac catheterization were significantly younger and had a lower mortality than those not selected (51% versus 85%, P < .0001) even if they were not revascularized (58%). Mortality for patients undergoing percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA) was 60% (n = 55) and 19% (n = 16) for coronary artery bypass graft surgery (CABG). Sixty percent (n = 150) of registered patients were judged eligible for a trial of early revascularization. Trial-eligible patients were significantly younger (65.4 +/- 11.0 versus 70.6 +/- 11.9 years, P < .001), had an earlier median time to shock onset after MI (6.5 versus 17.5 hours, P = .003), and had lower mortality (62% versus 73%, P = .077) than ineligible patients.
Patients diagnosed with cardiogenic shock complicating acute MI are a heterogeneous group. Those eligible for a trial of early revascularization tended to have lower mortality. Patients selected to undergo cardiac catheterization had lower mortality whether or not they were revascularized. Emergent PTCA and CABG are promising treatment modalities for cardiogenic shock, but biased case selection for treatment may confound the data. Whether PTCA and CABG reduce mortality and which patient subgroups benefit most remain to be determined in a randomized clinical trial.
心源性休克仍然是急性心肌梗死(MI)住院患者死亡的主要原因。本研究旨在探讨(1)当前心源性休克的范围,(2)可能适合早期血运重建试验的患者比例,以及(3)早期血运重建对死亡率的明显影响。
美国和比利时的19个参与中心对所有诊断为心源性休克的患者进行了前瞻性登记。共登记了251例患者。平均年龄为67.5±11.7岁,43%为女性。8%的心源性休克由急性二尖瓣反流或室间隔破裂引起。5%的患者存在导致休克发生的并发疾病,2%为单纯右心室休克。在其余214例患者中,14%的患者心电图有与“非透壁性”MI相关的非特异性表现。MI后至休克诊断的中位时间为8小时。总体住院死亡率为66%。临床选择进行心脏导管检查的患者比未选择的患者明显年轻且死亡率更低(51%对85%,P<.0001),即使他们未进行血运重建(58%)。接受经皮腔内冠状动脉成形术(PTCA)的患者死亡率为60%(n=55),冠状动脉旁路移植术(CABG)的患者死亡率为19%(n=16)。60%(n=150)的登记患者被判定适合早期血运重建试验。适合试验的患者明显更年轻(65.4±11.0岁对70.6±11.9岁,P<.001),MI后至休克发作的中位时间更早(6.5小时对17.5小时,P=.003),且死亡率低于不适合的患者(62%对73%,P=.077)。
诊断为并发急性MI的心源性休克患者是一个异质性群体。适合早期血运重建试验的患者死亡率往往较低。选择进行心脏导管检查的患者无论是否进行血运重建死亡率都较低。急诊PTCA和CABG是心源性休克有前景的治疗方式,但治疗的病例选择偏倚可能会混淆数据。PTCA和CABG是否能降低死亡率以及哪些患者亚组获益最大仍有待在随机临床试验中确定。