Falcone D, Broyles R
University of Oklahoma.
J Health Polit Policy Law. 1994 Fall;19(3):583-95. doi: 10.1215/03616878-19-3-583.
Race continues to impede access to health services, for acute as well as long-term care. Whites, for example, use disproportionately more days of nursing home care than nonwhites, not simply because they are more likely to be private payers and, therefore, are preferred over nonwhites: the difference in utilization persists even among those whose nursing home stays are covered by Medicare. Using data from a study of patients awaiting alternative placement in North Carolina acute care general hospitals in 1991, this article examines racial differences in discharge delay, that is, in the time between when a patient is medically ready for discharge to another form of care and when he or she actually is discharged. Logistic regression and ordinary least squares are used heuristically to identify patient characteristics associated with delay, and two-way analyses of variance are used to document the independent effect of race. The results indicate that race has substantial independent explanatory power. This finding is reinforced by the analysis of variance with controls for the patient's payment source for long-term care, chronic condition or special care requirements, demographic attributes, family cooperativeness, whether the patient had a behavior problem that impeded the discharge planning process, and whether there was a financial problem in arranging for the patient's discharge. The inescapable conclusion is that nursing homes discriminate on the basis of race in admitting patients. This practice is patently objectionable; it also is costly to hospitals, thus to society, since hospitals bear the direct costs of delayed discharges and hospitals do not keep costs to themselves. While research is needed to determine whether the North Carolina findings are replicable in other states, past research suggests that the problem is not confined to this state.
种族问题继续阻碍人们获得医疗服务,无论是急性护理还是长期护理。例如,白人使用疗养院护理的天数比非白人多得多,这不仅仅是因为他们更有可能是自费支付者,因此比非白人更受青睐:即使在那些疗养院护理费用由医疗保险支付的人群中,使用情况的差异仍然存在。本文利用1991年对北卡罗来纳州急性护理综合医院等待替代安置的患者进行的一项研究数据,研究了出院延迟方面的种族差异,即患者在医学上准备好出院到另一种护理形式与实际出院之间的时间。启发式地使用逻辑回归和普通最小二乘法来识别与延迟相关的患者特征,并使用双向方差分析来记录种族的独立影响。结果表明,种族具有显著的独立解释力。通过对患者长期护理支付来源、慢性病或特殊护理需求、人口统计学属性、家庭合作性、患者是否有妨碍出院计划过程的行为问题以及安排患者出院时是否存在财务问题进行控制的方差分析,这一发现得到了加强。不可避免的结论是,疗养院在接收患者时存在种族歧视。这种做法显然令人反感;它对医院乃至社会也造成了成本,因为医院承担了延迟出院的直接成本,而且医院不会独自承担成本。虽然需要进行研究以确定北卡罗来纳州的研究结果在其他州是否可复制,但过去的研究表明,这个问题并不局限于该州。