Ralls K
Q Rev Biol. 1976 Jun;51(2):245-76. doi: 10.1086/409310.
Females are larger than males in more species of mammals than is generally supposed. A provisional list of the mammalian cases is provided. The phenomenon is not correlated with an unusually large degree of male parental investment, polyandry, greater aggressiveness in females than in males, greater development of weapons in females, female dominance, or matriarchy. The phenomenon may have evolved in a variety of ways, but it is rarely, if ever, the result of sexual selection acting upon the female sex. The most common selective pressures favoring large size in female mammals are probably those associated with the fact that a big mother is often a better mother and those resulting from more intense competintion among females for some resource than among males. It appears that, in general, more than one such pressure must affect the females of a species, and that their combined effects must not be countered by even stronger selective pressures favoring large size in males, before the result is that of larger size in the female sex. Sexual selection may often be operating upon the male sux in mammals even when it is smaller. Present knowledge about the species of mammals in which females are lager than males is quite rudimentary. Much more information is needed before we will be able to speak of the selective pressures accounting for the phenomenon with any reasomable degree of certainty. Perhaps the most fruitful approach would be a series of field studies of groups of related species in which females are larger in some species and males are larger in others.
在哺乳动物中,雌性比雄性体型更大的物种数量比人们普遍认为的要多。文中提供了一份哺乳动物相关案例的暂定清单。这种现象与雄性超常的亲代投资程度、一妻多夫制、雌性比雄性更具攻击性、雌性武器发育更完善、雌性主导地位或母系社会无关。这种现象可能以多种方式进化而来,但很少(如果有的话)是性选择作用于雌性的结果。有利于雌性哺乳动物体型变大的最常见选择压力,可能与这样一个事实有关:体型大的母亲往往是更好的母亲,以及雌性之间为争夺某些资源的竞争比雄性之间更激烈所导致的结果。一般来说,似乎必须有不止一种这样的压力影响一个物种的雌性,而且它们的综合影响不能被更强大的有利于雄性体型变大的选择压力抵消,才会导致雌性体型更大的结果。即使雄性体型较小,性选择在哺乳动物中也可能经常作用于雄性。目前关于雌性比雄性体型更大的哺乳动物物种的知识还相当初步。在我们能够以任何合理的确定性程度谈论导致这种现象的选择压力之前,还需要更多信息。也许最富有成效的方法是对一组相关物种进行一系列实地研究,在这些物种中,有些物种雌性体型更大,而有些物种雄性体型更大。