Roberts J E, Burchinal M R, Bailey D B
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.
Am J Ment Retard. 1994 Nov;99(3):231-49.
Communicative interactions of preschool children with and without disabilities in classrooms of same or mixed ages were compared. Sixteen children with developmental disabilities (most with mild or moderate mental retardation) and 32 children without disabilities between 1.5 and 4.5 years of age were randomly assigned at the beginning of the school year to either a same- or mixed-age grouping of 6 children. They were observed 6 months later interacting with classmates in a standard free-play environment. Results showed that children in mixed-age classes took more turns in conversations with partners with disabilities than did children in same-age classrooms. They also received more turns from their partners with disabilities, which were more often responses than initiations in the mixed-age as compared to same-age classes. In contrast, during communicative interactions with partners without disabilities, children in both types of classes did not significantly differ in number or types of turns. Children of a similar developmental level also had similar communicative interaction styles.
对同龄或不同龄班级中有残疾和无残疾的学龄前儿童的交流互动进行了比较。16名发育障碍儿童(大多数为轻度或中度智力迟钝)和32名1.5至4.5岁无残疾儿童在学年开始时被随机分配到6人一组的同龄或不同龄班级中。6个月后,观察他们在标准自由游戏环境中与同学的互动情况。结果显示,与同龄班级的儿童相比,不同龄班级的儿童在与残疾伙伴的对话中轮流发言的次数更多。他们从残疾伙伴那里得到的轮流发言机会也更多,与同龄班级相比,在不同龄班级中这些机会更多是回应而非主动发起。相比之下,在与无残疾伙伴的交流互动中,两类班级的儿童在轮流发言的数量或类型上没有显著差异。发育水平相似的儿童也有相似的交流互动方式。