Barrett G R, Miller C, Richardson K
Mississippi Sports Medicine & Orthopaedic Center, Jackson 39202.
Am J Knee Surg. 1995 Winter;8(1):13-8; discussion 18-9.
Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction using the semitendinosus tendon has seen renewed interest recently. Puddu described a procedure in which the tendon is harvested at its insertion on the tibia with a bone plug. This study evaluates the efficacy of this approach and examines the long-term results. Between 1982 and 1986, 77 patients underwent this type of procedure; 51 (66%) patients who were reexamined comprised the study group. Thirty-five patients had acute tears, and 16 patients had chronic tears. Follow-up was both objective and subjective with an average follow-up of 7 years and 3 months (range: 5.8 to 9.2 years). In the acute group, six patients (17%) had a 2+ Lachman and seven (22%) had a 1+ Lachman. Pivot shift was 2+ to 3+ in three patients (8.6%) and 1+ in seven patients (22%). KT-100 results were > 5 mm in eight patients (23.3%). In the chronic group, four patients (25%) had 2+ and four had a 1+ Lachman. Seven patients (44%) had a positive pivot shift test. Five patients had > 5 mm difference. Using regression analysis, the KT-1000 results correlated well with the Lachman and pivot shift tests. Chronicity and partial meniscectomy were associated with a poor result. Although this technique has undergone an evolution and improvement to a four-strand reconstruction in recent years, the results of this review indicate satisfactory results can be obtained, especially in the acute setting.
最近,使用半腱肌腱进行前交叉韧带(ACL)重建再次引起了人们的关注。普杜描述了一种手术方法,即带着骨栓在胫骨止点处采集肌腱。本研究评估了这种方法的疗效并检查了长期结果。1982年至1986年间,77例患者接受了此类手术;51例(66%)接受复查的患者组成了研究组。35例患者为急性撕裂,16例患者为慢性撕裂。随访包括客观和主观两方面,平均随访时间为7年3个月(范围:5.8至9.2年)。在急性组中,6例患者(17%)Lachman试验为2+,7例患者(22%)为1+。3例患者(8.6%)轴移试验为2+至3+,7例患者(22%)为1+。8例患者(23.3%)的KT-100测量结果>5mm。在慢性组中,4例患者(25%)Lachman试验为2+,4例为1+。7例患者(44%)轴移试验阳性。5例患者的差异>5mm。使用回归分析,KT-1000测量结果与Lachman试验和轴移试验相关性良好。慢性损伤和部分半月板切除术与预后不良相关。尽管近年来该技术已发展并改进为四股重建,但本综述结果表明,尤其是在急性损伤情况下,可获得满意的结果。