Narasimhan T R, Craig A, Arellano L, Harper N, Howie L, Menache M, Birnbaum L, Safe S
Department of Veterinary Physiology and Pharmocology, Texas A&M University, College Station 77843-4466.
Fundam Appl Toxicol. 1994 Nov;23(4):598-607. doi: 10.1006/faat.1994.1146.
Improvements in risk assessment require better linkage of exposure to response by the determination of target tissue dose. The relative sensitivity of several responses in female B6C3F1 mice was compared on the basis of administered and target tissue dose spanning 3 orders of magnitude. Twenty-four hours after administration, [3H]TCDD was detected in the heart, spleen, kidney, uterus, thymus, lung, and liver, and the highest concentrations were noted in the liver, uterus, and lung. At doses from 5 to 25 ng/kg, hepatic [3H]TCDD levels associated with the cytosolic and nuclear subcellular fractions increased from 12 to 62% of the total liver levels and then decreased at higher doses. At the two lowest doses used in the enzyme induction study, 5 and 10 ng/kg, the levels of specifically bound nuclear Ah receptor complex liganded with [3H]TCDD were 2.3 and 2.5 fmol/mg protein. Slightly higher levels of nuclear Ah receptor complex were observed at doses between 25 and 100 ng/kg (i.e., 3.6 to 4.2 fmol/mg protein) and a steep dose-dependent increase in nuclear Ah receptor levels was noted at doses of 500, 1000, and 5000 ng/kg (8.0, 39.3, and 92.8 fmol/mg protein, respectively). The dose-dependent effects of [3H]TCDD on hepatic Cyp1a-1 and Cyp1a-2 mRNA levels, ethoxyresorufin O-deethylase (EROD) activity, and the splenic antibody plaque-forming cell (PFC) response to sheep red blood cells were also determined; the latter response was determined 9 days after administration of TCDD. Statistically significant induction of hepatic Cyp1a-1 was observed at lower doses (25 ng/kg) than any other marker, followed by induction of EROD and PFCs expressed per spleen or per 10(6) cells which was observed at 100 ng TCDD/kg and at higher doses. Cyp1a-2 was elevated significantly relative to control at doses > or = 1000 ng/kg. The ED50 value for PFCs/10(6) cells was the lowest of the variables analyzed and was not statistically significantly different from control (91 +/- 92 ng/kg). A 50% increase in Cyp1a-2 and Cyp1a-1 mRNA levels was observed at doses of 736 +/- 132 and 1630 +/- 431 ng/kg, respectively. Due to variability in response in PFCs/spleen and the submaximal induction of EROD activity, ED50 values could not be calculated for these responses. The analyses indicate that the immunosuppressive response (when normalized for the number of spleen cells) may be depressed by administered doses as low as 90 ng TCDD/kg body weight. A 50% increase in Cyp1a-1 or Cyp1a-2 was observed at higher administered doses (1630 or 736 ng/kg, respectively.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)
风险评估的改进需要通过确定靶组织剂量来更好地将暴露与反应联系起来。基于跨越3个数量级的给药剂量和靶组织剂量,比较了雌性B6C3F1小鼠几种反应的相对敏感性。给药后24小时,在心脏、脾脏、肾脏、子宫、胸腺、肺和肝脏中检测到[3H]TCDD,肝脏、子宫和肺中的浓度最高。在5至25 ng/kg的剂量下,与胞质和核亚细胞组分相关的肝脏[3H]TCDD水平从肝脏总水平的12%增加到62%,然后在更高剂量下下降。在酶诱导研究中使用的两个最低剂量,即5和10 ng/kg时,与[3H]TCDD结合的特异性结合核Ah受体复合物水平分别为2.3和2.5 fmol/mg蛋白质。在25至100 ng/kg的剂量下观察到核Ah受体复合物水平略高(即3.6至4.2 fmol/mg蛋白质),在500、1000和5000 ng/kg的剂量下观察到核Ah受体水平呈陡峭的剂量依赖性增加(分别为8.0、39.3和92.8 fmol/mg蛋白质)。还确定了[3H]TCDD对肝脏Cyp1a-1和Cyp1a-2 mRNA水平、乙氧基异吩恶唑酮O-脱乙基酶(EROD)活性以及脾脏对绵羊红细胞的抗体空斑形成细胞(PFC)反应的剂量依赖性影响;后者的反应在给予TCDD 9天后确定。在比任何其他标志物更低的剂量(25 ng/kg)下观察到肝脏Cyp1a-1有统计学意义的诱导,其次是在100 ng TCDD/kg及更高剂量下观察到的每脾脏或每10(6)个细胞表达的EROD和PFC的诱导。Cyp1a-2在剂量≥1000 ng/kg时相对于对照显著升高。PFCs/1(6)个细胞的ED50值是所分析变量中最低的,且与对照无统计学显著差异(91±92 ng/kg)。分别在736±132和1630±431 ng/kg的剂量下观察到Cyp1a-2和Cyp1a-1 mRNA水平增加50%。由于PFCs/脾脏反应的变异性和EROD活性的次最大诱导,无法计算这些反应的ED50值。分析表明,免疫抑制反应(按脾脏细胞数量标准化)可能在低至90 ng TCDD/kg体重的给药剂量下受到抑制。在较高的给药剂量(分别为1630或736 ng/kg)下观察到Cyp1a-1或Cyp1a-2增加50%。(摘要截断于400字)