Katz M, Abbey S, Rydall A, Lowy F
Toronto Hospital, Department of Psychiatry, Ontario, Canada.
Psychosomatics. 1995 Jan-Feb;36(1):33-41. doi: 10.1016/S0033-3182(95)71705-4.
Forty-one psychiatric consultations on medical-surgical inpatients for competency to refuse medical treatment were studied retrospectively. The competent (n = 16) and incompetent (n = 25) patients were compared in terms of demographic data, diagnoses, clinical variables, details about treatment refusal, and outcome following competency assessment. The incompetent patients tended to be men, the focus of more urgent requests, and to have refused operations. The incompetent patients tended to have organic brain syndromes; the competent patients had personality disorders, adjustment disorders, or no psychiatric diagnosis. Ultimate acceptance of treatment initially refused was common in both groups; differential psychiatric interventions were recommended. The process of psychiatric consultation appeared to facilitate acceptance of treatment initially refused.
对41例因拒绝治疗能力而接受精神科会诊的内科-外科住院患者进行了回顾性研究。对有行为能力(n = 16)和无行为能力(n = 25)的患者在人口统计学数据、诊断、临床变量、拒绝治疗的细节以及行为能力评估后的结果方面进行了比较。无行为能力的患者多为男性,提出的紧急请求更多,且倾向于拒绝手术。无行为能力的患者往往患有器质性脑综合征;有行为能力的患者患有个性障碍、适应障碍或无精神科诊断。两组中最初拒绝的治疗最终被接受的情况都很常见;建议采取不同的精神科干预措施。精神科会诊过程似乎有助于接受最初拒绝的治疗。