Keks N, McGrath J, Lambert T, Catts S, Vaddadi K, Burrows G, Varghese F, George T, Hustig H, Burnett P
Alfred Hospital, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
Acta Psychiatr Scand. 1994 Nov;90(5):358-65. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0447.1994.tb01607.x.
A double-blind, randomized study of parallel group design comparing remoxipride and thioridazine (dose range 150-600 mg/day of either drug) was undertaken at 11 Australian centres. A total of 144 patients (remoxipride = 73, thioridazine = 71) with DSM-III-R schizophrenia or schizophreniform disorder commenced the study, and 89 patients (remoxipride = 45, thioridazine = 44) completed the 6 weeks of the trial. The mean daily doses at last rating were 404 mg (remoxipride) and 378 mg (thioridazine). Initial Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale scores decreased by a mean 8.7 points in both remoxipride and thioridazine groups. Equivalent treatment responses were also confirmed by Clinical Global Impression. During the study, sedatives or hypnotics were needed by 68% of the remoxipride patients and 51% of the thioridazine patients. Thioridazine was associated with more postural hypotension, drowsiness, increased sleep, headache, dizziness on rising, dry mouth, sexual dysfunction and weight gain, while remoxipride patients reported more insomnia. There were no differences between remoxipride and thioridazine on dystonia, hypokinesia, dyskinesia, rigidity and akathisia. The results indicate that remoxipride has similar antipsychotic efficacy to thioridazine but causes fewer side effects.
在澳大利亚的11个中心开展了一项双盲、平行组设计的随机研究,比较瑞莫必利和硫利达嗪(两种药物的剂量范围均为150 - 600毫克/天)。共有144例患有DSM - III - R精神分裂症或精神分裂症样障碍的患者(瑞莫必利组73例,硫利达嗪组71例)开始了该研究,89例患者(瑞莫必利组45例,硫利达嗪组44例)完成了为期6周的试验。末次评定时的平均日剂量分别为404毫克(瑞莫必利)和378毫克(硫利达嗪)。瑞莫必利组和硫利达嗪组的初始简明精神病评定量表评分平均下降了8.7分。临床总体印象也证实了两组的治疗反应相当。在研究期间,68%的瑞莫必利组患者和51%的硫利达嗪组患者需要使用镇静剂或催眠药。硫利达嗪与更多的体位性低血压、嗜睡、睡眠增加、头痛、起立性头晕、口干、性功能障碍和体重增加有关,而瑞莫必利组患者报告有更多的失眠症状。瑞莫必利和硫利达嗪在肌张力障碍、运动减退、运动障碍、强直和静坐不能方面没有差异。结果表明,瑞莫必利与硫利达嗪具有相似的抗精神病疗效,但副作用更少。