Roversi R, Milandri G L, Ricci S, Rossi G, Dal Monte P R
Unità Sanitaria Locale 29, Ospedale Bellaria, Bologna Est.
Radiol Med. 1994 Dec;88(6):834-9.
Two hundred and eight cirrhotic patients with HCC underwent TACE with a standardized technique. Kaplan-Meier survival rates and 12, 24 at 36 months were 62%, 44% and 25%, respectively. Compared with 407 untreated patients, our series had a longer life expectancy, i.e., from 15 months after treatment on. Life experience was statistically different with the L-R test between the groups selected by Child-Pugh cirrhosis staging (p = 0.00000); all 8 Child-Pugh C patients died within 7 months; a high statistical difference was found between Child-Pugh A and B groups (p = 0.00012). Life experience was statistically different with the L-R test between the four groups selected by tumor size and spread (p = 0.012); statistical significance was not reached between contiguous groups in group vs. group comparisons. The patients with monofocal tumors, regardless of size, survive longer than those with multifocal and infiltrative (p = 0.0010) and those with multifocal (p = 0.0029) lesions. Hazard analysis, according to the stratified Cox model, proved tumor-size and Child-Pugh staging to be prognostic factors (p = 0.00027; p = 0.00000) which exhibit a highly significant correlation with each other (p = 0.00000). With the proportional hazard Cox model, tumor characteristics and Child-Pugh stage resulted to be highly significant independent prognostic factors (p = 0.013 and p = 0.000, respectively). Patient survival rates were graphically plotted against literature rates in 407 untreated patients classified by tumor size and by the Child-Pugh method: the two-year survival rates were higher in the subgroups of patients submitted to TACE. To conclude, TACE is an effective treatment not only for multifocal HCCs, but also for large monofocal and infiltrative HCCs. In contrast, TACE is quite useless in the patients with Child-Pugh C cirrhosis.
208例肝硬化合并肝癌患者接受了标准化技术的经动脉化疗栓塞术(TACE)。采用Kaplan-Meier法分析生存率,患者12个月、24个月和36个月的生存率分别为62%、44%和25%。与407例未接受治疗的患者相比,本研究队列的预期寿命更长,即治疗后15个月起。通过对数秩检验(L-R检验)发现,不同Child-Pugh肝硬化分期组之间的生存情况具有统计学差异(p = 0.00000);所有8例Child-Pugh C级患者均在7个月内死亡;Child-Pugh A级和B级组之间存在高度统计学差异(p = 0.00012)。根据肿瘤大小和扩散情况分为四组,通过L-R检验发现不同组之间的生存情况具有统计学差异(p = 0.012);组间比较中相邻组之间未达到统计学显著性。无论肿瘤大小,单灶性肿瘤患者的生存期均长于多灶性和浸润性肿瘤患者(p = 0.0010)以及多灶性肿瘤患者(p = 0.0029)。根据分层Cox模型进行的风险分析表明,肿瘤大小和Child-Pugh分期是预后因素(p = 0.00027;p = 0.00000),二者之间存在高度显著相关性(p = 0.00000)。采用比例风险Cox模型分析,肿瘤特征和Child-Pugh分期均为高度显著的独立预后因素(分别为p = 0.013和p = 0.000)。根据肿瘤大小和Child-Pugh方法对407例未接受治疗的患者进行分类,并将本研究患者的生存率与文献报道的生存率进行对比绘图:接受TACE治疗的患者亚组的两年生存率更高。总之,TACE不仅是治疗多灶性肝癌的有效方法,也是治疗大的单灶性和浸润性肝癌的有效方法。相比之下,TACE对Child-Pugh C级肝硬化患者几乎无效。