Celli P, Nofrone I, Palma L, Cantore G, Fortuna A
Department of Neurological Sciences, La Sapienza University, Rome, Italy.
Neurosurgery. 1994 Dec;35(6):1018-34; discussion 1034-5. doi: 10.1227/00006123-199412000-00003.
The records of 137 patients with supratentorial oligodendroglioma treated surgically between 1953 and 1986 were reviewed. The tumors were rated histologically benign or malignant. In the 105 patients followed up with a minimum observation time of 5 years to December 1991, the mean postoperative survival was 90.2 months (standard error, 9), the median 64 months (standard error, 9.6), the 5-year survival rate 52.4%, and the 10-year survival rate 24%. Sixteen possible prognostic factors, broken down into two or more variables each, were considered in the survival study on univariate methods (5-year survival rate, survival curves, and Cox's hazard function) and on multivariate analysis according to Cox's stepwise proportional hazards model. The latter showed that variables correlated positively with survival were benign histological findings (P, 0.000), postoperative radiation therapy (P, 0.004), and time of operation from 1977 to 1986 (P, 0.044) in 105 patients of the whole series, and period of surgery from 1977 to 1986 (P, 0.000), subtotal or total surgical resection of the tumor (P, 0.001), and radiation therapy (P, 0.005) in the subgroup of 79 patients operated on for benign tumors. However, the most interesting point to emerge from the study was the relevance of admission clinical status to the survival of patients who did not receive radiation therapy and to the prognostic response of those who did. Of the 40 patients with seizures and negative neurological status--Clinical Syndrome A--the 10 who did not receive radiation therapy had survived as long as the 30 who did (5-year survival rate, 80 versus 67%; P, not significant; median survival, 122 versus 85 months; Breslow and Mantel-Cox P, not significant), whereas of the 65 patients with intracranial hypertension and/or neurological deficits--Clinical Syndrome non-A--the 18 who did not receive radiation therapy had short survival times, and the 47 who did fared significantly better (5-year survival rate, 11 versus 53%; P, 0.002; median survival, 32 versus 64 months; Breslow and Mantel-Cox P, 0.000). These findings were not significantly affected by the exclusion of malignant neoplasms and in the group of benign tumors, in which the histological characteristics have not been found to be significantly different between those with A and those with non-A clinical syndrome, did not depend on different frequencies of subtotal or total tumor removal.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)
回顾了1953年至1986年间接受手术治疗的137例幕上少突胶质细胞瘤患者的记录。对肿瘤进行了组织学良性或恶性分级。在105例随访至1991年12月且最短观察时间为5年的患者中,术后平均生存期为90.2个月(标准误为9),中位数为64个月(标准误为9.6),5年生存率为52.4%,10年生存率为24%。在单变量方法(5年生存率、生存曲线和Cox风险函数)的生存研究以及根据Cox逐步比例风险模型进行的多变量分析中,考虑了16个可能的预后因素,每个因素又细分为两个或更多变量。后者显示,在整个系列的105例患者中,与生存呈正相关的变量为组织学良性表现(P = 0.000)、术后放疗(P = 0.004)以及1977年至1986年的手术时间(P = 0.044);在79例接受良性肿瘤手术的亚组患者中,与生存呈正相关的变量为1977年至1986年的手术时间(P = 0.000)、肿瘤次全或全切除(P = 0.001)以及放疗(P = 0.005)。然而,该研究中最有趣的一点是入院时的临床状态与未接受放疗患者的生存以及接受放疗患者的预后反应之间的相关性。在40例有癫痫发作且神经状态阴性——临床综合征A的患者中,未接受放疗的10例患者与接受放疗的30例患者存活时间一样长(5年生存率分别为80%和67%;P无统计学意义;中位生存期分别为122个月和85个月;Breslow和Mantel-Cox检验P无统计学意义),而在65例有颅内高压和/或神经功能缺损——临床综合征非A的患者中,未接受放疗的18例患者生存时间较短,接受放疗的47例患者情况明显更好(5年生存率分别为11%和53%;P = 0.002;中位生存期分别为32个月和64个月;Breslow和Mantel-Cox检验P = 0.000)。排除恶性肿瘤对这些结果没有显著影响,在良性肿瘤组中,A临床综合征患者与非A临床综合征患者的组织学特征未发现有显著差异,也不取决于肿瘤次全或全切除的不同频率。(摘要截断于400字)