Kuks J B, Cook M J, Fish D R, Stevens J M, Shorvon S D
Department of Neurology, State University Hospital, Groningen, Netherlands.
Lancet. 1993 Dec 4;342(8884):1391-4. doi: 10.1016/0140-6736(93)92754-h.
The connection between hippocampal sclerosis and childhood febrile seizures (CFS) is a contentious issue in the study of epilepsy. We investigated 107 patients with drug-resistant epilepsy by high-resolution volumetric magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). 20 had a history of CFS, 45 had focal (26) or diffuse (19) hippocampal volume loss (HVL). The frequency of CFS was significantly (p < 0.001) higher in the patients with HVL, especially of the diffuse pattern, compared to other epileptic patients without HVL and to the general population. Furthermore, the severity of HVL was greatest in those with a history of CFS. No other clinical or demographic features were associated with either a history of CFS or HVL. The frequency of CFS in patients with other structural congenital causes of epilepsy did not differ from that in a general population. Although these findings show that hippocampal sclerosis is strongly associated with a history of CFS, they do not indicate whether this is a causal relationship. If CFS do cause some cases of hippocampal sclerosis, this can not be the only mechanism, as 64% of those with HVL gave no history of CFS. As diffuse HVL is more strongly associated with a history of CFS than focal HVL, it is also possible that CFS convert pre-existing congenital focal abnormalities into diffuse hippocampal sclerosis. Given the possibility that CFS may cause hippocampal damage and epilepsy, they require urgent medical intervention.
海马硬化与儿童热性惊厥(CFS)之间的联系是癫痫研究中的一个有争议的问题。我们通过高分辨率容积磁共振成像(MRI)对107例耐药性癫痫患者进行了调查。20例有CFS病史,45例有局灶性(26例)或弥漫性(19例)海马体积缩小(HVL)。与其他无HVL的癫痫患者及一般人群相比,HVL患者,尤其是弥漫性模式患者的CFS发生率显著更高(p < 0.001)。此外,有CFS病史者的HVL严重程度最大。没有其他临床或人口统计学特征与CFS病史或HVL相关。其他结构性先天性癫痫病因患者的CFS发生率与一般人群无异。虽然这些发现表明海马硬化与CFS病史密切相关,但它们并未表明这是否为因果关系。如果CFS确实导致了某些海马硬化病例,这不可能是唯一的机制,因为64%有HVL的患者没有CFS病史。由于弥漫性HVL比局灶性HVL与CFS病史的相关性更强,CFS也有可能将先前存在的先天性局灶性异常转化为弥漫性海马硬化。鉴于CFS可能导致海马损伤和癫痫,它们需要紧急医疗干预。