Geard C R, Jones J M, Schiff P B
Center for Radiological Research, College of Physicians & Surgeons, Columbia University, New York, N.Y. 10032.
J Natl Cancer Inst Monogr. 1993(15):89-94.
The cytotoxic effects of Taxol and/or ionizing radiation were evaluated in four human tumor cell lines. The recognized antimicrotubular effects of the drug leading to transitory accumulations of cells in the G2/M phase of the cell cycle, the most radiosensitive phase of the cycle, prompted this assessment of the potential for Taxol to function as a cell-cycle, phase-specific radiosensitizer. Taxol alone was cytotoxic to all four cell lines at low (< 25 nM) concentrations. A Taxol concentration of 10 nM for 24 hours led to 48, 15, 8, and 4.4% of cells retaining clonogenic potential for melanoma, two cervical carcinomas, and astrocytoma, respectively. There were significant Taxol concentration-time-dependent differences in response between the cell lines. Cell lines also showed significant differences in their responses to ionizing radiation. Combined treatment resulted in a demonstration of radiation sensitization with the astrocytoma and melanoma cell lines but not with the cervical carcinoma cell lines. Sensitizer enhancement ratios at the 10% cell survival level were 1.8 for 10 nM Taxol for 24 hours with the astrocytoma cells and 1.2 for 40 nM Taxol for 24 hours with the melanoma cells. The cervical carcinoma cell lines showed an additive effect for radiation and Taxol at all drug concentrations; that is, combined treatments elicit an additive or supra-additive response with, however, no simple relationship between Taxol concentration, Taxol time of treatment, and radiation dose in optimizing cytotoxic effectiveness. Combined modality treatments using relatively low concentrations of Taxol and ionizing radiation can result in an enhanced response and, at the least, an additive response, which could be advantageous in a clinical setting.
在四种人类肿瘤细胞系中评估了紫杉醇和/或电离辐射的细胞毒性作用。该药物公认的抗微管作用会导致细胞在细胞周期的G2/M期短暂积累,而G2/M期是细胞周期中对辐射最敏感的阶段,这促使人们评估紫杉醇作为细胞周期特异性辐射增敏剂的潜力。单独使用紫杉醇时,在低浓度(<25 nM)下对所有四种细胞系均具有细胞毒性。10 nM的紫杉醇处理24小时后,黑色素瘤、两种子宫颈癌细胞系和星形细胞瘤中分别有48%、15%、8%和4.4%的细胞保留克隆形成潜力。各细胞系对紫杉醇的反应存在显著的浓度-时间依赖性差异。细胞系对电离辐射的反应也存在显著差异。联合治疗显示星形细胞瘤和黑色素瘤细胞系有辐射增敏作用,而子宫颈癌细胞系则没有。在10%细胞存活水平下,对于星形细胞瘤细胞,10 nM紫杉醇处理24小时的增敏增强比为1.8;对于黑色素瘤细胞,40 nM紫杉醇处理24小时的增敏增强比为1.2。在所有药物浓度下,子宫颈癌细胞系对辐射和紫杉醇显示出相加效应;也就是说,联合治疗引发相加或超相加反应,然而,在优化细胞毒性效力方面,紫杉醇浓度、紫杉醇处理时间和辐射剂量之间没有简单的关系。使用相对低浓度的紫杉醇和电离辐射进行联合治疗可导致反应增强,至少是相加反应,这在临床环境中可能是有利的。