Sugimoto K, Hirata M, Takishima T, Ohwada T, Shimazu S, Kakita A
Department of Traumatology and Critical Care Medicine, School of Medicine, Kitasato University, Kanagawa, Japan.
J Am Coll Surg. 1994 Oct;179(4):443-8.
The efficiency of intraoperative peritoneal lavage (IOPL) and peritoneal drainage in patients with generalized peritonitis remains controversial. The benefit of large volume IOPL, using a newly designed device, and of peritoneal drainage were evaluated in 101 patients with generalized peritonitis.
Patients were divided into two groups, one treated by mechanically assisted IOPL (group 1), and the other treated by manual IOPL (group 2). They were further divided into two groups, one undergoing drainage (DR group) and the other undergoing no drainage (ND group). Based on data in the progress notes, patients in these groups were compared with each other with respect to disease process, volume of IOPL fluid, incidence of infectious complications, and other prognostic factors.
In group 1, the incidence of infectious complications was significantly lower than in group 2 (10.8 versus 62.9 percent, p < 0.01). Patients who underwent operative treatment 12 hours or more after onset of peritonitis had a lower incidence of infection following high volume IOPL (greater than or equal to 30 L) compared with those patients who underwent low volume IOPL. The incidence of infectious complications was significantly higher in the DR group (32.8 versus 12.9 percent).
A large volume of saline (greater than or equal to 30 L) was needed for IOPL. The new device for IOPL proved to be very successful and efficient. When IOPL was successful, it seemed that peritoneal drainage did not provide any additional benefits to the treatment of generalized peritonitis.
术中腹腔灌洗(IOPL)和腹腔引流在弥漫性腹膜炎患者中的有效性仍存在争议。本研究对101例弥漫性腹膜炎患者评估了使用新设计装置进行大量IOPL及腹腔引流的益处。
患者分为两组,一组接受机械辅助IOPL治疗(第1组),另一组接受手动IOPL治疗(第2组)。每组再进一步分为两组,一组进行引流(DR组),另一组不进行引流(ND组)。根据病程记录中的数据,对这些组患者在疾病进程、IOPL液量、感染性并发症发生率及其他预后因素方面进行相互比较。
第1组感染性并发症的发生率显著低于第2组(10.8%对62.9%,p<0.01)。腹膜炎发作12小时或更长时间后接受手术治疗的患者,与接受少量IOPL的患者相比,大量IOPL(大于或等于30L)后感染发生率较低。DR组感染性并发症的发生率显著更高(32.8%对12.9%)。
IOPL需要大量生理盐水(大于或等于30L)。新的IOPL装置被证明非常成功且有效。当IOPL成功时,腹腔引流似乎并未为弥漫性腹膜炎的治疗带来任何额外益处。