Keary K, Fitzpatrick C
St. Clare's Unit, Children's Hospital, Dublin, Ireland.
Child Abuse Negl. 1994 Jul;18(7):543-8. doi: 10.1016/0145-2134(94)90080-9.
This study set out to provide information on children's disclosures of sexual abuse during formal child sexual abuse investigation. The study was carried out in a Child Sexual Abuse Assessment Unit based in a Children's Hospital, staffed by a multidisciplinary team and receiving referrals from community child protection agencies, pediatricians, general practitioners, and the police. Two hundred and fifty one children who had full assessments over a 12-month period formed the study group. They were divided at time of referral into two groups: (a) those who had previously told someone about abusive experiences prior to investigations; and (b) those who had not. There was a strongly positive correlation between having previously told someone about sexual abuse and disclosure of such abuse during formal investigation. There was also a strongly positive correlation between not having previously told someone and not disclosing during formal investigation. Age was an important variable, with children under 5 being least likely to disclose abuse during formal investigation, irrespective of whether they had previously told someone about abuse. Disclosure of sexual abuse during investigation was strongly positively correlated with abuse being regarded as confirmed. These results call into question the value of formal sexual abuse investigation in children who have not previously told someone about abuse. The value of a "nonleading" interview style with young children is also called into question, given that many young children who had previously disclosed abuse, did not repeat this information during formal investigation in which "nonleading" interviews were used.
本研究旨在提供有关儿童在正式的儿童性虐待调查中披露性虐待情况的信息。该研究在一家儿童医院的儿童性虐待评估部门开展,该部门由一个多学科团队组成,接收来自社区儿童保护机构、儿科医生、全科医生和警方的转介。在12个月期间接受全面评估的251名儿童构成了研究组。在转介时,他们被分为两组:(a)那些在调查前曾向他人讲述过虐待经历的儿童;(b)那些未曾讲述过的儿童。之前向他人讲述过性虐待情况与在正式调查中披露此类虐待情况之间存在强烈的正相关。之前未向他人讲述过与在正式调查中未披露之间也存在强烈的正相关。年龄是一个重要变量,5岁以下的儿童在正式调查中披露虐待情况的可能性最小,无论他们之前是否向他人讲述过虐待情况。在调查中披露性虐待情况与虐待被确认为属实之间存在强烈的正相关。这些结果让人质疑对之前未向他人讲述过虐待情况的儿童进行正式性虐待调查的价值。鉴于许多之前披露过虐待情况的幼儿在使用“非引导性”访谈方式的正式调查中并未重复这些信息,对幼儿采用“非引导性”访谈方式的价值也受到质疑。