Brown W F, Dellon A L, Campbell W W
Department of Neurology, New England Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts.
Muscle Nerve. 1994 Nov;17(11):1336-42. doi: 10.1002/mus.880171113.
The role of electrodiagnosis in managing patients with focal neuropathies is discussed from the differing perspectives of a peripheral nerve surgeon and a practitioner of electrodiagnostic medicine. Both clinical evaluation and electrodiagnosis are useful methodologies, each having limitations. Dr. Dellon labels the overreliance on electrodiagnosis and the "WOG" (Word of God) syndrome, and describes its signs, symptoms, and treatment. Dr. Brown contends Dr. Dellon's crusade is misdirected. The exchange is an eloquent polemic on the virtues and foibles of these different approaches to evaluating peripheral nerve function and the imperative to practice them in a complementary rather than a contentious manner.
从周围神经外科医生和电诊断医学从业者的不同角度,讨论了电诊断在局灶性神经病患者管理中的作用。临床评估和电诊断都是有用的方法,但各自都有局限性。戴隆博士将过度依赖电诊断称为“上帝的旨意”(WOG)综合征,并描述了其体征、症状和治疗方法。布朗博士认为戴隆博士的讨伐方向有误。这场交流是对这些评估周围神经功能的不同方法的优点和缺点以及以互补而非争论的方式实践它们的必要性进行的有力辩论。