Sclafani A, Ackroff K
Department of Psychology, Brooklyn College, City University of New York 11210.
Physiol Behav. 1994 Aug;56(2):399-405. doi: 10.1016/0031-9384(94)90213-5.
Flavor preferences conditioned by glucose and fructose were compared using two training methods. With the simultaneous method preferences can be reinforced by the flavor and/or the postingestive consequences of nutrients, whereas with the delayed method preferences are reinforced only by postingestive nutritive effects. In Experiment 1, food-deprived rats displayed similar preferences for flavors (CS+) added to an 8% glucose or 8% fructose solution over flavors (CS-) added to a noncaloric saccharin solution (simultaneous conditioning). Other rats learned to prefer a CS+ flavor paired with the delayed (10 min) presentation of 8% glucose over a CS- flavor paired with delayed saccharin. Fructose failed to condition a flavor preference with the delayed paradigm. Taken together, these data suggest that the preference for a flavor mixed in a fructose solution is reinforced by the sweet taste, not the postingestive effects of the sugar. Experiment 2 tested this idea by devaluing the taste of the sugar solutions by quinine adulteration. Rats initially avoided both glucose-quinine and fructose-quinine solutions in favor of a saccharin solution. Following one-bottle training, they came to prefer the glucose-quinine but not the fructose-quinine solution over the saccharin solution. The glucose-trained rats also showed stronger preferences for sucrose-quinine solutions than did the fructose-trained rats. These findings, along with other recent data, indicate that fructose-conditioned preferences are based primarily on the sugar's palatable taste. Glucose, in contrast, can condition strong preferences based on its taste as well as its postingestive actions.
采用两种训练方法比较了由葡萄糖和果糖形成的味觉偏好。使用同时训练法时,味觉偏好可通过营养素的味道和/或摄入后效应得到强化,而使用延迟训练法时,味觉偏好仅通过摄入后的营养效应得到强化。在实验1中,食物被剥夺的大鼠对添加到8%葡萄糖溶液或8%果糖溶液中的味道(条件刺激+)的偏好,高于添加到无热量糖精溶液中的味道(条件刺激-)(同时训练)。其他大鼠学会了偏好与延迟(10分钟)呈现的8%葡萄糖配对的条件刺激+味道,而不是与延迟呈现的糖精配对的条件刺激-味道。果糖在延迟范式下未能形成味觉偏好。综合来看,这些数据表明,对果糖溶液中混合味道的偏好是由甜味强化的,而非糖的摄入后效应。实验2通过用奎宁掺假来降低糖溶液的味道,对这一观点进行了测试。大鼠最初避开葡萄糖-奎宁溶液和果糖-奎宁溶液,而选择糖精溶液。在单瓶训练后,它们开始偏好葡萄糖-奎宁溶液而非果糖-奎宁溶液,而不是糖精溶液。接受葡萄糖训练的大鼠对蔗糖-奎宁溶液的偏好也比接受果糖训练的大鼠更强。这些发现以及其他近期数据表明,果糖形成的偏好主要基于糖的可口味道。相比之下,葡萄糖既能基于其味道也能基于其摄入后作用形成强烈的偏好。