Walker R D, Howard M O, Lambert M D, Suchinsky R
Addictions Treatment Center, Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Seattle, WA 98108.
West J Med. 1994 Jul;161(1):39-44.
Prescriptive standards of clinical conduct--practice guidelines--have proliferated throughout medicine over the past decade. Practicing physicians are confronted with a plethora of guidelines developed for different purposes by a diverse body of public and private organizations. We review factors contributing to the growth of guidelines, their desirable features, and consequences, legal and otherwise, of implementing guidelines. Few studies have examined whether, and under what conditions, guidelines are effective in changing physicians' practices and patients' health. Nonetheless, expectations for guidelines remain high because they are one of the only instruments of health care reform that promises to improve the quality of care while reducing overall health care costs. Efforts to develop guidelines are likely to continue unabated for the foreseeable future. Additional research comparing different methods of developing and disseminating guidelines is needed.
在过去十年中,临床行为的规范性标准——实践指南——在整个医学领域大量涌现。执业医师面临着众多由各种公共和私人组织出于不同目的制定的指南。我们回顾了促成指南发展的因素、其理想特征以及实施指南在法律及其他方面的后果。很少有研究考察指南是否以及在何种条件下能有效改变医生的行为和患者的健康状况。尽管如此,对指南的期望仍然很高,因为它们是医疗改革中唯一有望在提高医疗质量的同时降低总体医疗成本的工具之一。在可预见的未来,制定指南的努力可能会持续不减。还需要进行更多研究来比较制定和传播指南的不同方法。