Chan A W, Pristach E A, Welte J W
Research Institute on Addictions, New York State Office of Alcoholism and Substance Abuse Services, Buffalo 14203-1016.
Alcohol Clin Exp Res. 1994 Jun;18(3):695-701. doi: 10.1111/j.1530-0277.1994.tb00933.x.
The brief MAST (B-MAST) questionnaire was used to detect alcoholism in three populations, namely, alcoholics in treatment, clinical outpatients, and the general population. Nearly all the alcoholics in treatment tested positive in the B-MAST (99.2%), for lifetime as well as for current (past year) alcohol-related problems. Among the clinical outpatients and general population, 35.6% and 20.2% respectively, tested positive for lifetime alcohol problems, but only 19.6% and 7.6%, respectively, tested positive for past-year alcohol problems. The sensitivity/specificity of the B-MAST (lifetime) was 64.7%/90.0% and 48.3%/96.4% in the clinical outpatients and general population, respectively. Even lower sensitivity (28.2%) was obtained when the B-MAST was used to detect past-year alcohol problems in the general population sample. The poor sensitivity of the B-MAST in the general population was probably because most of the B-MAST questions deal with severe alcohol problems, and they are not sufficiently sensitive to detect those who drank heavily but who had not yet developed these alcohol problems. Anomalous responses to the two questions about "normal drinker" and to the question about "attendance in AA meeting" also contributed (< 3%) to inflated positive B-MAST scores. There were gender differences, and to a lesser extent, racial differences (Whites versus Blacks), in the responses to individual B-MAST questions in the three subject populations, with more males than females in each group reporting more alcohol-related problems. However, there were no gender and racial differences in the average B-MAST scores among those clinical outpatients and general population subjects who tested positive.
简短的密歇根酒精中毒筛选测验(B-MAST)问卷被用于在三类人群中检测酒精中毒情况,这三类人群分别是正在接受治疗的酗酒者、临床门诊患者以及普通人群。几乎所有正在接受治疗的酗酒者在B-MAST测验中呈阳性(99.2%),无论是终生还是当前(过去一年)与酒精相关的问题。在临床门诊患者和普通人群中,分别有35.6%和20.2%的人在终生酒精问题测验中呈阳性,但在过去一年酒精问题测验中呈阳性的分别仅为19.6%和7.6%。B-MAST(终生)在临床门诊患者和普通人群中的敏感度/特异度分别为64.7%/90.0%和48.3%/96.4%。当使用B-MAST在普通人群样本中检测过去一年酒精问题时,甚至获得了更低的敏感度(28.2%)。B-MAST在普通人群中的敏感度较低,可能是因为B-MAST的大多数问题涉及严重的酒精问题,对于检测那些饮酒量大但尚未出现这些酒精问题的人来说,它们的敏感度不够。对关于“正常饮酒者”的两个问题以及关于“参加戒酒互助会”问题的异常回答也导致(<3%)B-MAST阳性得分虚高。在这三类受试人群中,对B-MAST各个问题的回答存在性别差异,在较小程度上也存在种族差异(白人与黑人),每组中报告更多与酒精相关问题的男性多于女性。然而,在那些呈阳性的临床门诊患者和普通人群受试者中,B-MAST平均得分不存在性别和种族差异。