Roberti I, Reisman L, Lieberman K V, Burrows L
Department of Pediatrics, Mount Sinai School of Medicine, New York, NY 10029.
Clin Transplant. 1994 Aug;8(4):405-8.
Withdrawal of steroid therapy in renal allograft recipients remains controversial despite the many side effects of this treatment. We have previously presented data on 16 pediatric renal transplant recipients in whom prednisone was withdrawn 6 months or later post-transplantation. To assess the impact of steroid withdrawal, we retrospectively compared this group of patients (Group 1) with a group of 12 patients (Group 2) with renal transplants who continued on prednisone. The groups were compared as to age, sex, ethnicity, source of graft, number of HLA-DR mismatches and incidence of ATN in the immediate postoperative period. The only significant difference was that Group 2 was older. Group 1 had significantly fewer episodes of early acute rejection in the first 6 months post-transplantation than the control group (3/16 vs 8/12, p = 0.009) but nevertheless, without prednisone, had significantly more late acute rejections (11/16 vs 3/12, p = 0.03). Acute rejections occurred as late as 4 years after withdrawal of steroids. Only 5 of the 16 patients in Group 1 have maintained stable graft function without steroids. All of these patients are now alive more than 5 years after steroid withdrawal. In comparing these patients to the other 11, who failed a trial of steroid withdrawal, we found that a serum creatinine of less than 1.7 mg/dl at the time of withdrawal of steroids was predictive of a successful outcome (p = 0.03). In conclusion, withdrawing steroids in pediatric renal allograft recipients has a high risk of late acute rejection and subsequent graft loss, especially for those who have higher baseline creatinine levels.
尽管类固醇疗法存在诸多副作用,但在肾移植受者中停用该疗法仍存在争议。我们之前曾公布过16例小儿肾移植受者的数据,这些患者在移植后6个月或更晚停用了泼尼松。为了评估停用类固醇的影响,我们回顾性地将这组患者(第1组)与另一组12例继续使用泼尼松的肾移植患者(第2组)进行了比较。比较了两组患者的年龄、性别、种族、移植物来源、HLA - DR错配数以及术后早期急性肾小管坏死的发生率。唯一显著的差异是第2组患者年龄更大。第1组在移植后的前6个月发生早期急性排斥反应的次数明显少于对照组(3/16 vs 8/12,p = 0.009),但尽管如此,在没有泼尼松的情况下,晚期急性排斥反应明显更多(11/16 vs 3/12,p = 0.03)。急性排斥反应在停用类固醇后长达4年时仍会发生。第1组的16例患者中只有5例在没有类固醇的情况下维持了稳定的移植肾功能。所有这些患者在停用类固醇后5年多仍存活。在将这些患者与另外11例停用类固醇试验失败的患者进行比较时,我们发现停用类固醇时血清肌酐低于1.7 mg/dl可预测成功结局(p = 0.03)。总之,在小儿肾移植受者中停用类固醇有发生晚期急性排斥反应及随后移植肾丢失的高风险,尤其是对于那些基线肌酐水平较高的患者。