Whalen C K, Henker B, O'Neil R, Hollingshead J, Holman A, Moore B
Department of Psychology and Social Behavior, University of California, Irvine 92717.
Health Psychol. 1994 Jul;13(4):319-25. doi: 10.1037//0278-6133.13.4.319.
Although optimistic bias has been well documented for adults, little is known about how children view their own risks vis-à-vis those of their peers. Two studies of 6th graders examined optimism and the degree of differentiation in perceived risks across diverse health, lifestyle, and environmental problems. The findings revealed perceptions of relative invulnerability and highly differentiated risk assessments. The strongest levels of optimism emerged for controllable and stigmatizing events such as illicit drugs, smoking, and AIDS. The effects of gender, assessment context, and methodological variations were minimal. Discussion focused on the implications for health-promoting interventions with school-age children, the need for developmental information about risk perception processes, and the difficulty of distinguishing realistic from biased optimism.
尽管成年人的乐观偏差已有大量记载,但对于儿童如何看待自己与同龄人相比的风险却知之甚少。两项针对六年级学生的研究考察了乐观情绪以及在各种健康、生活方式和环境问题上感知风险的差异程度。研究结果揭示了相对无懈可击的认知和高度分化的风险评估。对于诸如非法药物、吸烟和艾滋病等可控且有污名化的事件,出现了最强程度的乐观情绪。性别、评估背景和方法差异的影响微乎其微。讨论集中在对学龄儿童健康促进干预措施的影响、关于风险感知过程的发展信息的必要性,以及区分现实乐观与偏差乐观的困难。