Alper P R
Department of Medicine, University of California Medical Center, San Francisco.
JAMA. 1994 Nov 16;272(19):1523-7.
It is generally agreed that too few physicians have chosen careers in primary care. The advent of managed care as a popular method of health care provision is now affecting primary care physicians in ways that may further discourage enthusiasm for the practice of primary care and have an unintended negative effect on the primary care physician supply. In addition, the early implementation of the resource-based relative value scale by Medicare and some insurance carriers has been less beneficial to primary care physicians than expected and may even have been harmful to general internists. Efforts to improve the position of primary care physicians in relation to payers and among peers are hindered by the fact that, as a group, primary care physicians are less affluent, less influential, and greatly outnumbered by their more specialized colleagues. Consequently, some of the support currently directed toward primary care may be more apparent than real. My proposals, which aim both to protect and to enhance primary care practice, are the creation of separate primary care fee schedules and separate primary care budgets within health plans, changes in consumer protection rules that intrude on primary care practice, and the development of statewide primary care associations for mutual support and greater bargaining power. Some aspects of contracting and gatekeeping require further study.
人们普遍认为,选择从事初级保健工作的医生太少了。作为一种流行的医疗保健提供方式,管理式医疗的出现正以一些方式影响着初级保健医生,这些方式可能会进一步打消人们对初级保健工作的热情,并对初级保健医生的供应产生意想不到的负面影响。此外,医疗保险和一些保险公司早期实施的基于资源的相对价值尺度对初级保健医生的益处不如预期,甚至可能对普通内科医生有害。改善初级保健医生相对于付款人和同行地位的努力受到这样一个事实的阻碍,即作为一个群体,初级保健医生不如他们更专业的同事富裕、有影响力,而且人数远远多于他们。因此,目前一些针对初级保健的支持可能更多是表面的而非实际的。我的提议旨在保护和加强初级保健实践,包括在健康计划中制定单独的初级保健费用表和单独的初级保健预算,改变侵犯初级保健实践的消费者保护规则,以及建立全州范围的初级保健协会以相互支持并增强议价能力。签约和把关的一些方面需要进一步研究。