Bellini M, Capannini D
Università degli Studi di Bologna, Istituto di Psichiatria P. Ottonello.
Minerva Psichiatr. 1994 Sep;35(3):175-86.
It is a much debated question whether suicide risk is higher for cancer patients in comparison to general population. We analyse this problem by a literature review and focus on specific risk groups. We have identified two different research topics: (1) The study of cancer prevalence among suicides. (2) The study of suicide incidence among cancer patients. Mainly on a basis of the latter and more homogeneous researches, we have outlined that cancer diagnosis involves an increased suicide risk. It is difficult on the contrary to explain the sources of suicidal behaviour by means of the heterogeneous literature data. Most of authors agree that suicide risk is highest during the first to second year since diagnosis. The risk can be attributed to the information on cancer diagnosis, but mainly to the seriousness of neoplastic disease, because of negative short-term outcome of most serious patients. Furthermore the risk can be attributed to the period immediately following discharge from oncologic and surgical wards, especially for long-term patients who suffer from distress given by the treatment itself. Then it is at risk the relapse after symptom remission. The high-risk patients are those suffering from the most severe and rapidly progressive neoplasms, treated by chemotherapy or affected by terminal illness with intractable pain. Patients with previous psychiatric history (particularly including alcohol dependence and depression) are likely to kill themselves in the remission phase of illness. In conclusion cancer patients who commit suicide, are not a homogeneous group. The relationships between cancer, depression and suicide are crucial, because severe depression is particularly frequent among cancer patients but is sometimes misdiagnosed and lacking in treatment.
与普通人群相比,癌症患者的自杀风险是否更高是一个备受争议的问题。我们通过文献综述来分析这个问题,并关注特定的风险群体。我们确定了两个不同的研究主题:(1)自杀者中癌症患病率的研究。(2)癌症患者自杀发生率的研究。主要基于后者以及更具同质性的研究,我们概述了癌症诊断会增加自杀风险。相反,利用异质性的文献数据很难解释自杀行为的根源。大多数作者一致认为,自杀风险在诊断后的第一年到第二年最高。这种风险可归因于癌症诊断信息,但主要归因于肿瘤疾病的严重性,因为大多数重症患者的短期预后不佳。此外,这种风险可归因于从肿瘤病房和外科病房出院后的 immediately following 期,特别是对于那些因治疗本身而痛苦的长期患者。然后,症状缓解后的复发也存在风险。高危患者是那些患有最严重且进展迅速的肿瘤、接受化疗或患有伴有顽固性疼痛的晚期疾病的患者。有既往精神病史(特别是包括酒精依赖和抑郁症)的患者在疾病缓解期可能会自杀。总之,自杀的癌症患者并非一个同质群体。癌症、抑郁症和自杀之间的关系至关重要,因为严重抑郁症在癌症患者中尤为常见,但有时会被误诊且缺乏治疗。