Racalbuto A, Trombatore G, Greco L, Gresta S, De Luca B, Scilletta B, Puleo S, Licata A
Istituto di I Clinica Chirurgica Generale e Terapia Chirurgica, Università degli Studi di Catania.
Minerva Chir. 1994 May;49(5):397-406.
Given its anatomical location the small intestine is the section of the digestive tract most inaccessible to objective clinical and instrumental examination. For this reason, traditional investigation methods provide inadequate data. In the barium meal X-ray, images are superimposed and the barium excessively fragmented due to the tortuosity and length of the intestinal loop. Access problems limit the value of endoscopy. The indications to angiography are fairly restrictive. Ultrasound and CT scans provide no conclusive evidence in this area. The so-called Small Bowel Enema technique based on the direct infusion of an opaque contrast medium after duodenal intubation remains the only way to obtain images with a satisfactory diagnostic value and should be the method of choice in examinations of the small intestine. Introduced in the twenties, the value of the technique was long questioned, mainly because it was difficult to perform correctly and it is only quite recently that several decisive technological innovations have made it highly reliable. The present paper describes its use on a series of patients with suspected pathologies of the small intestine requiring surgical treatment. The aim is to specify the correct indications to this technique as well as its limitations with a view to promoting its appropriate use in routine practice. MATERIALS AND METHODS. The study covers 42 small bowel enemas performed on 29 male and 13 female patients aged 12-85 years. Indications to the enema included chronic abdominal pain in 28.5%, chronic diarrhea in 21.4%, pain+diarrhea in 14%, subocclusion in 16.5%, faecal blood in 11.9%, abdominal pain+diarrhea+intestinal haemorrhage in 4.7%, anaemia in 2.4%. We adopted the Sellink technique involving intubation with a French 14 Bilbao-Dotter probe and the infusion of 200-350 cc barium sulphate in a 90%-70% P/V concentration at a speed of 100 ml/min, followed by the infusion of 1000-1500 cc 0.5-1% methylcellulose in a 50-50 mixture with water for double contrast purposes. Mean duration of procedure 35-40 mins. RESULTS. We found lesions of the small intestine in 18 cases or 45% (true positives) and no alterations in 18 or 42.8% (true negatives). In 3 cases (7%) the examination was inconclusive. One false positive and one false negative complete the series, making a diagnostic accuracy of 89.1%. In 23.8% of the total series the diagnosis of Crohn's disease was confirmed; cancerous lesions were found in 11.9% and adhesions following earlier surgery in 9.7%. Surgery confirmed this diagnosis in 10 cases (5 tumours, 3 stenoses caused by adhesion fragments, 2 Crohn's disease) and disproved it in one case. Biopsy was used, for objective confirmation in 5 cases (2 Crohn's disease, 3 negatives). In the other cases reliance was placed on clinical course and the patients' response to treatment. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS. Examination of our results reveals that in most clinical cases the small bowel enema was used to confirm suspected Crohn's disease (31 cases out of 42) and with a very high degree of diagnostic accuracy (96.7%). In line with data in the literature we decided to base the indication to this examination on certain primary symptoms such as chronic abdominal pain, diarrhea, blood in the faeces, whether in isolation or in combination. On this rather general basis the diagnosis of Crohn's disease concerned only 23.8% of the cases studied, an incidence that rose dramatically in the few cases in which the indications were made more specific. We therefore conclude that the adoption of more restrictive criteria will improve the cost-benefit ratio for this test. Another major pathology in which small bowel enema possesses a high diagnostic value is partial obstruction of the small intestine.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)
鉴于其解剖位置,小肠是消化道中最难通过客观临床和器械检查进行评估的部分。因此,传统的检查方法所提供的数据并不充分。在钡餐X线检查中,由于肠袢的迂曲和长度,图像相互重叠,钡剂过度分散。检查通路问题限制了内镜检查的价值。血管造影的适应证相当有限。超声和CT扫描在这方面无法提供确凿的证据。基于十二指肠插管后直接注入不透X线造影剂的所谓小肠灌肠技术,仍然是获得具有满意诊断价值图像的唯一方法,应作为小肠检查的首选方法。该技术于20世纪20年代引入,其价值长期受到质疑,主要是因为难以正确操作,直到最近一些决定性的技术创新才使其高度可靠。本文描述了该技术在一系列疑似小肠病变需要手术治疗患者中的应用。目的是明确该技术的正确适应证及其局限性,以促进其在常规实践中的合理应用。材料与方法。本研究涵盖了对29名男性和13名女性患者(年龄在12 - 85岁之间)进行的42次小肠灌肠检查。灌肠的适应证包括慢性腹痛(28.5%)、慢性腹泻(21.4%)、腹痛 + 腹泻(14%);不全梗阻(16.5%)、便血(11.9%)、腹痛 + 腹泻 + 肠道出血(4.7%)、贫血(2.4%)。我们采用Sellink技术,使用法国14号Bilbao - Dotter导管插管,并以100ml/min的速度注入2体积分数为90% - 70%的硫酸钡200 - 350cc,随后以1000 - 1500cc 0.5% - 1%的甲基纤维素与水按1:1混合注入以进行双重对比。检查平均持续时间为35 - 40分钟。结果。我们发现18例(45%)小肠有病变(真阳性),18例(42.8%)无改变(真阴性)。3例(7%)检查结果不明确。该系列中有1例假阳性和1例假阴性,诊断准确率为89.1%。在整个系列中,23.8%的病例确诊为克罗恩病;发现癌性病变的占11.9%,既往手术术后粘连的占9.7%。手术证实了10例的诊断(5例肿瘤、3例由粘连碎片引起的狭窄、2例克罗恩病),1例诊断未被证实。5例(2例克罗恩病、3例阴性)进行了活检以客观证实诊断。其他病例则依据临床病程和患者对治疗的反应。讨论与结论。对我们的结果进行分析后发现,在大多数临床病例中,小肠灌肠用于确诊疑似克罗恩病(42例中有31例),且诊断准确率非常高(96.7%)。根据文献数据,我们决定将该检查的适应证基于某些主要症状,如慢性腹痛、腹泻、便血,无论是单独出现还是合并出现。基于这个相当宽泛的标准,所研究病例中仅有23.8%被诊断为克罗恩病,而在少数适应证更具体的病例中,这一发病率显著上升。因此,我们得出结论,采用更严格的标准将提高该检查的成本效益比。小肠灌肠具有高诊断价值的另一种主要病变是小肠部分梗阻。(摘要截选至400字)