Wenderoth P
Department of Psychology, University of Sydney, New South Wales, Australia.
Perception. 1994;23(2):221-36. doi: 10.1068/p230221.
It has long been accepted that amongst patterns which are bilaterally symmetrical, those which have their axis of symmetry vertical are more saliently symmetrical than patterns whose axis of symmetry is at some other orientation. The evidence regarding the relative salience of other orientations of axis of symmetry is somewhat more equivocal. In experiment 1, subjects were required to discriminate between symmetric or random-dot patterns when the axis of symmetry was at one of eighteen different orientations, spaced 10 degrees apart, both clockwise and counterclockwise of vertical to horizontal. The data indicated that vertical was most salient, then horizontal but that, unlike in the classical oblique effect for contrast sensitivity, performance for precisely diagonal axes was better than that for surrounding axis orientations. Additional data (from experiments 2 and 3) also showed that the salience of vertical and horizontal axes of symmetry can be manipulated extensively by varying the range of stimuli presented, presumably by manipulating the scanning or attentional strategy adopted by the observer. Many previous studies of symmetry perception may have confounded hard-wired salience for vertical symmetry with scanning or attentional strategies.
长期以来,人们一直认为,在双侧对称的图案中,对称轴垂直的图案比对称轴处于其他方向的图案更显著地对称。关于对称轴其他方向的相对显著性的证据则有些模棱两可。在实验1中,当对称轴处于垂直于水平方向顺时针和逆时针每隔10度的18个不同方向之一时,要求受试者区分对称或随机点图案。数据表明,垂直方向最显著,其次是水平方向,但与经典的对比度敏感性倾斜效应不同的是,精确对角线方向的表现优于周围轴方向。其他数据(来自实验2和3)还表明,通过改变呈现的刺激范围,大概是通过操纵观察者采用的扫描或注意力策略,可以广泛地操纵垂直和水平对称轴的显著性。许多以前关于对称性感知的研究可能将垂直对称的固有显著性与扫描或注意力策略混淆了。