Gail M H
Biostatistics Branch, National Cancer Institute, Bethesda, Md.
Chest. 1994 Dec;106(6 Suppl):287S-292S.
This article reviews the design and findings of LCSG Protocol 771, a randomized double-blind comparison of postoperative adjuvant intrapleural bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) against saline solution placebo control in 473 patients with resected T1N0, T1N1, or T2N0 non-small cell lung cancer. Patients were randomized from August 30, 1977, through October 20, 1980, and follow-up ended on January 1, 1990. There was no evidence of improved survival or time to recurrence among patients given BCG in contrast to earlier promising findings. A calculation suggests that false-positive results due to chance are not uncommon in small preliminary studies, indicating the need for larger confirmatory trials such as LCSG Protocol 771. Other contributions from this Protocol are also reviewed, including data on BCG toxicity, immunologic effects, patterns of recurrence, and identification of prognostic risk groups.
本文回顾了肺癌研究组(LCSG)771号方案的设计与研究结果。该方案是一项随机双盲对照试验,将473例接受手术切除的T1N0、T1N1或T2N0非小细胞肺癌患者分为两组,一组接受术后胸腔内注射卡介苗(BCG)辅助治疗,另一组接受生理盐水安慰剂对照。患者于1977年8月30日至1980年10月20日随机分组,随访于1990年1月1日结束。与早期令人鼓舞的研究结果相反,接受卡介苗治疗的患者在生存率或复发时间方面并无改善迹象。一项计算表明,在小型初步研究中,偶然出现假阳性结果并不罕见,这表明需要进行更大规模的确证性试验,如LCSG 771号方案。本文还回顾了该方案的其他贡献,包括卡介苗毒性、免疫效应、复发模式以及预后风险组识别等方面的数据。