Spanos W J, Day T, Jose B, Paris K, Lindberg R D
Department of Radiation Oncology, University of Louisville School of Medicine, James Graham Brown Cancer Center, Kentucky 40292.
Gynecol Oncol. 1994 Jul;54(1):35-9. doi: 10.1006/gyno.1994.1162.
From 1982 through 1989, 56 patients with Stage III epithelial carcinoma of the ovary received intraperitoneal chromic phosphate following chemotherapy and second look (52 pts) or as the only postsurgical management (4 pts). Median follow-up was 48 months (range of 24 to 108 months). The 4 patients treated following primary surgery with P-32 without chemotherapy had microscopic abdominal disease (3 pts) or complete reduction of gross abdominal disease (1 pt), and their 5-year survival was 100%. Of the 52 patients treated with P-32 following PAC chemotherapy, 23 were pathologic negative, 15 had microscopic residual, and 14 had gross residual at second look. The 5-year survival following second look was 75% for negative, 48% for microscopic, and 32% for gross residual. There were 4 Grade 3 GI complications (7%). There were no complications in the 38 patients who received the P-32 within 12 hr of surgery. The use of P-32 as an adjuvant for Stage I and II epithelial carcinoma of ovary has been found to be effective in prior GOG trials. We have expanded the selection criteria in patients with Stage III carcinoma to include those who can be surgically reduced to microscopic residual at primary surgery or second look following chemo reduction. Because of multiple prognostic variables affecting survival in Stage III ovarian cancer, a randomized study with control arm would be necessary to draw firm conclusions regarding the effectiveness of P-32. The 5-year survival in this group of patients compares favorably to published reports.
1982年至1989年期间,56例Ⅲ期卵巢上皮癌患者在化疗及二次探查术后(52例)或作为唯一的术后治疗(4例)接受了腹腔内注射磷酸铬。中位随访时间为48个月(范围24至108个月)。4例在初次手术后未接受化疗仅接受P-32治疗的患者,有镜下腹部病变(3例)或腹部大块病变完全消退(1例),其5年生存率为100%。在接受PAC化疗后接受P-32治疗的52例患者中,23例病理检查为阴性,15例有镜下残留,14例在二次探查时有大块残留。二次探查后的5年生存率,阴性者为75%,镜下残留者为48%,大块残留者为32%。有4例出现3级胃肠道并发症(7%)。在手术12小时内接受P-32治疗的38例患者中无并发症发生。在既往的妇科肿瘤学组(GOG)试验中,已发现P-32作为Ⅰ期和Ⅱ期卵巢上皮癌的辅助治疗有效。我们扩大了Ⅲ期癌患者的选择标准,将那些在初次手术或化疗减瘤后的二次探查时可手术减至镜下残留的患者纳入其中。由于影响Ⅲ期卵巢癌生存的预后变量较多,有必要进行一项设有对照组的随机研究,以就P-32的有效性得出确凿结论。该组患者的5年生存率与已发表的报告相比情况良好。