Salaman R A, Shandall A, Morgan R H, Fligelstone L, Davies W T, Lane I F
Cardiff Vascular Unit, University Hospital of Wales, UK.
Br J Surg. 1994 May;81(5):661-3. doi: 10.1002/bjs.1800810509.
Results of preoperative investigation of 127 patients who underwent elective aortic aneurysm repair during a 3-year period were examined and compared with findings at operation. The accuracy of preoperative computed tomography (CT) and intravenous digital subtraction angiography (DSA) in assessing proximal and distal aneurysm extent was compared. From a total of 118 CT scans, ten of 12 suprarenal aneurysms were correctly predicted, with 11 false positives (positive predictive value 48 per cent, sensitivity 83 per cent, specificity 90 per cent). After 103 DSA investigations, six of ten suprarenal aneurysms were correctly predicted with one false positive (positive predictive value 86 per cent, sensitivity 60 per cent, specificity 99 per cent). Using CT, 30 of 54 aneurysmal iliac arteries were correctly diagnosed with 20 false positives (positive predictive value 60 per cent, sensitivity 56 per cent, specificity 88 per cent). Thirty-six of 48 aneurysmal iliac arteries were diagnosed correctly using DSA, with 32 false positives (positive predictive value 53 per cent, sensitivity 75 per cent, specificity 79 per cent). Intravenous DSA also provided useful information about renal and peripheral occlusive disease. Both investigations have their own specific limitations; clinicians should be aware of these when ordering and interpreting them.
对127例在3年期间接受择期主动脉瘤修复手术患者的术前检查结果进行了分析,并与手术中的发现进行了比较。比较了术前计算机断层扫描(CT)和静脉数字减影血管造影(DSA)在评估动脉瘤近端和远端范围方面的准确性。在总共118次CT扫描中,12例肾上腺上动脉瘤中有10例被正确预测,有11例假阳性(阳性预测值48%,敏感性83%,特异性90%)。在103次DSA检查后,10例肾上腺上动脉瘤中有6例被正确预测,有1例假阳性(阳性预测值86%,敏感性60%,特异性99%)。使用CT,54例髂动脉瘤中有30例被正确诊断,有20例假阳性(阳性预测值60%,敏感性56%,特异性88%)。使用DSA,48例髂动脉瘤中有36例被正确诊断,有32例假阳性(阳性预测值53%,敏感性75%,特异性79%)。静脉DSA还提供了有关肾和周围闭塞性疾病的有用信息。两种检查都有其特定的局限性;临床医生在开具检查单和解读检查结果时应予以注意。