Sher C, Mimouni M, Weitzen T, Waisman Y
Department of Emergency Medicine, Children's Medical Center of Israel, Petah Tikva.
Isr J Med Sci. 1994 Aug;30(8):651-6.
Although controversy still exists about dispensing medical advice over the telephone, such services are widely offered by pediatricians in the USA. In Israel, however, such services have not yet been developed. In a joint project of the Moked Keshev (a private medical help line) at Magen David Adom (national ambulance service) and the Children's Medical Center of Israel, the first pediatric telephone advice service in Israel was established. In this study we analyzed 512 consecutive incoming calls received during the first 11 months of service operation. Of these, 42% of calls concerned children in the 1 month to 1 year age group. Unexpectedly, calls were almost evenly distributed throughout the week with a slight decrease on Fridays and Saturdays (sabbath), and 45.7% of the calls were received during the morning shift. The three most common reasons for contact were: of a general nature such as fever (23%), gastrointestinal problems (19%), and medical questions (18%). In only 20.7% of the cases were the patients advised to go to the nearest hospital emergency department, emphasizing the non-emergent nature of the calls. At the time of follow-up (within 24 h), patient status was assessed as: improved (73.7%), same (22.6%), and worse (3.8%). Of those who became worse, none required an emergency department evaluation. The present study demonstrates that a Pediatric Telephone Advice Service in Israel is technically functional, medically safe, and contributes to the health management of children.
尽管通过电话提供医疗建议仍存在争议,但美国的儿科医生广泛提供此类服务。然而,在以色列,此类服务尚未得到发展。在以色列国家救护车服务机构马根·大卫·阿多姆的莫克德·凯舍夫(一家私人医疗求助热线)与以色列儿童医疗中心的一个联合项目中,以色列首个儿科电话咨询服务得以设立。在本研究中,我们分析了服务运营的前11个月期间连续接到的512个来电。其中,42%的来电涉及1个月至1岁年龄组的儿童。出乎意料的是,来电在一周内几乎均匀分布,周五和周六(安息日)略有减少,45.7%的来电是在早班期间接到的。联系的三个最常见原因是:一般性问题,如发烧(23%)、胃肠道问题(19%)和医疗问题(18%)。只有20.7%的病例中,患者被建议前往最近的医院急诊科,这凸显了来电的非紧急性质。在随访时(24小时内),患者状况评估为:好转(73.7%)、不变(22.6%)和恶化(3.8%)。在病情恶化的患者中,无人需要急诊科评估。本研究表明,以色列的儿科电话咨询服务在技术上是可行的,在医疗上是安全的,并且有助于儿童的健康管理。