Böhm B, Milsom J W, Kitago K, Brand M, Fazio V W
Department of Colorectal Surgery, Cleveland Clinic Foundation, OH 44195.
Surg Endosc. 1994 Jun;8(6):677-81. doi: 10.1007/BF00678565.
In a prospective randomized study using a canine model, we compared the use of monopolar electrosurgery (EC) (n = 23) and the Nd:YAG Contact Laser (CL) (n = 21) on intra- and postoperative morbidity in laparoscopic large-bowel resection. In EC, cutting was performed with scissors and coagulation was performed with electrosurgery. In CL, cutting and coagulation were carried out with the Nd:YAG Contact Laser. Laparoscopic oncologic right colectomy with intraperitoneal ileocolic stapled anastomosis was performed in all dogs. Intraoperative smoke development, difficulty of dissection, hemostasis, and postoperative adhesions were judged using a five-point score. Two weeks after surgery, all dogs were sacrificed and zoopsy was carried out. Three dogs died postoperatively from pneumonia and one from an anastomotic leak. There were no other postoperative complications. Operative time was 135 min (range 105-180) in the CL group and 145 min (range 60-210) in the EC group. Intraoperative smoke development, difficulty of dissection, and postoperative amount of adhesions were not different between groups (P > 0.05). Hemostasis in the CL group (median score of 1, range 1-2) was significantly better (P = 0.01) than in the EC group (median score of 2, range 1-5). Scissors and electrosurgery as well as Nd:YAG Contact Laser can be used successfully in intestinal laparoscopic surgery. Although the use of the Contact Laser did not cause less postoperative morbidity than the conventional method, there was significantly better hemostasis using the Nd: YAG Contact Laser.
在一项使用犬类模型的前瞻性随机研究中,我们比较了单极电外科手术(EC)(n = 23)和Nd:YAG接触式激光(CL)(n = 21)在腹腔镜大肠切除术中的术中及术后发病率。在EC组中,使用剪刀进行切割,用电外科手术进行凝血。在CL组中,使用Nd:YAG接触式激光进行切割和凝血。所有犬均行腹腔镜肿瘤性右半结肠切除术并进行腹腔内回结肠吻合器吻合术。使用五分制评分来判断术中烟雾产生情况、解剖难度、止血情况及术后粘连情况。术后两周,所有犬均被处死并进行尸检。3只犬术后死于肺炎,1只死于吻合口漏。无其他术后并发症。CL组手术时间为135分钟(范围105 - 180分钟),EC组为145分钟(范围60 - 210分钟)。两组间术中烟雾产生情况、解剖难度及术后粘连量无差异(P > 0.05)。CL组的止血情况(中位数评分为1,范围1 - 2)明显优于EC组(中位数评分为2,范围1 - 5)(P = 0.01)。剪刀、电外科手术以及Nd:YAG接触式激光均可成功应用于腹腔镜肠道手术。虽然接触式激光的使用并未比传统方法减少术后发病率,但使用Nd:YAG接触式激光止血效果明显更好。