Wang N M, Huang T S
Department of Otolaryngology, Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, Taipei, Taiwan, R.O.C.
Changgeng Yi Xue Za Zhi. 1994 Jun;17(2):144-8.
In this study, twenty-five subjects have received phonosurgery of benign vocal pathology but persistent voice disorders postoperatively, characterized by a hoarse, low-pitched, soft voice or efforted phonation. Each subject had filled out a self-evaluation questionnaire of vocal behaviors before surgery and his vocal cords examined by ENT doctor with indirect laryngoscope or direct fiberscope. Voice evaluations was done based on perceptual and acoustic parameters preoperatively and postoperatively. Twenty-five subjects were grouped into three post-operative vocal rehabilitation programs: voice rest group, vocal hygiene group, and direct voice therapy group. The criteria in grouping were according to the subjects' amount of vocal use, environmental pressures, vocal abuse or misuse behaviors and time flexibility. The therapy strategies included reducing amount of vocal use, changing life style, analyzing environmental pressures and treating voice problems with established facilitating techniques. The post-surgical vocal rehabilitation program lasted three to six months. Each subject's voice parameters were reevaluated six months after surgery. The results of three vocal rehabilitation groups were compared with those before rehabilitation. The implication of this study is to provide a holistic voice treatment plan and obtain better surgical intervention results.
在本研究中,25名受试者接受了良性嗓音病变的嗓音外科手术,但术后仍存在持续性嗓音障碍,其特征为声音嘶哑、音调低沉、轻柔或发声费力。每位受试者在手术前都填写了一份嗓音行为自评问卷,并且由耳鼻喉科医生使用间接喉镜或直接纤维喉镜对其声带进行检查。术前和术后均基于感知和声学参数进行嗓音评估。25名受试者被分为三个术后嗓音康复项目组:噤声组、嗓音保健组和直接嗓音治疗组。分组标准依据受试者嗓音使用量、环境压力、嗓音滥用或误用行为以及时间灵活性。治疗策略包括减少嗓音使用量、改变生活方式、分析环境压力以及运用既定的促进技巧治疗嗓音问题。术后嗓音康复项目持续三至六个月。术后六个月对每位受试者的嗓音参数进行重新评估。将三个嗓音康复组的结果与康复前的结果进行比较。本研究的意义在于提供一个全面的嗓音治疗方案并获得更好的手术干预效果。