Allgulander C
Karolinska Institute, Stockholm, Sweden.
Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1994 Sep;51(9):708-12. doi: 10.1001/archpsyc.1994.03950090040006.
The diverging views on suicide risk in patients with morbid anxiety called for a sufficiently large study to estimate the suicide risk in patients with anxiety neurosis and depressive neurosis.
The identities of all 9912 patients with anxiety neurosis and all 38,529 patients with depressive neurosis in the national Psychiatric Case Register in Sweden between 1973 and 1983, without any other psychiatric diagnoses, were matched with the national Cause-of-Death Register. The observed causes of death among the 9910 patients who died in 1990 or earlier were compared with those expected in the general population.
There were 1481 determined and 265 undetermined suicides among the patients; ie, 18% of all deaths. The standardized mortality ratio of suicide before the age of 45 years among men and women with anxiety neurosis was 6.7 and 4.9, respectively; for depressive neurosis, 12.6 and 15.7, respectively. The suicide risk was much higher within 3 months of leaving the hospital. Standardized mortality ratios of death caused by ischemic heart disease and traumatic injury were marginally elevated among men in both diagnostic groups. Women in both categories were at increased risk for death caused by alcohol abuse and cirrhosis of the liver. Obstructive pulmonary disease was another notable cause of death, reflecting the aggravation of anxiety-depressive symptoms by airway obstruction or the effects of tobacco smoking.
The risk of completed suicide among former inpatients with primary anxiety neurosis was higher than in previous, smaller studies and higher yet in patients with depressive neurosis. This hazard may hopefully be reduced by optimizing immediate and long-term treatment for the severely affected.
对于患有病态焦虑症患者的自杀风险存在不同观点,这就需要进行一项规模足够大的研究,以评估焦虑性神经症和抑郁性神经症患者的自杀风险。
1973年至1983年间瑞典国家精神病病例登记册中所有9912例焦虑性神经症患者和所有38529例抑郁性神经症患者(无任何其他精神疾病诊断)的身份信息与国家死亡原因登记册进行了匹配。将1990年或更早死亡的9910例患者的实际死亡原因与一般人群预期的死亡原因进行了比较。
患者中确定为自杀的有1481例,未确定的有265例;即占所有死亡人数的18%。焦虑性神经症男性和女性45岁之前自杀的标准化死亡比分别为6.7和4.9;抑郁性神经症分别为12.6和15.7。出院后3个月内自杀风险要高得多。两个诊断组男性中因缺血性心脏病和创伤性损伤导致死亡的标准化死亡比略有升高。两类女性因酒精滥用和肝硬化导致死亡的风险增加。阻塞性肺病是另一个值得注意的死亡原因,这反映了气道阻塞或吸烟对焦虑抑郁症状的加重作用。
原发性焦虑性神经症既往住院患者完成自杀的风险高于以往规模较小的研究,而抑郁性神经症患者的自杀风险更高。通过优化对重症患者的即时和长期治疗,有望降低这种风险。