Goldhaber S Z, Agnelli G, Levine M N
Chest. 1994 Sep;106(3):718-24. doi: 10.1378/chest.106.3.718.
To test the hypothesis that a reduced dose of bolus recombinant human tissue-type plasminogen activator (rt-PA) (0.6 mg/kg/15 min, maximum of 50 mg) would result in fewer bleeding complications than standard 100 mg of rt-PA administered as a continuous infusion over 2 h among hemodynamically stable patients with pulmonary embolism (PE). Subsidiary objectives were to compare the two rt-PA regimens with respect to the following: (1) the rate of other adverse clinical events; (2) the magnitude of change from baseline on perfusion lung scans, pulmonary angiograms, or echocardiograms; and (3) the differences in coagulation parameters over time.
A double-blind, double-dummy, randomized, controlled trial.
Twenty-eight participating hospitals in the United States, Italy, and Canada.
Patients could be included if they had symptoms or signs of PE within 14 days of presentation as well as high-probability lung scans and/or pulmonary angiograms demonstrating PE.
Randomization was undertaken with a 2:1 allocation ratio to rt-PA 0.6 mg/kg/15 min (maximum of 50 mg) or to 100 mg/2 h. Ninety patients were randomized, and 87 patients were treated: 60 with bolus rt-PA and 27 with 2-h rt-PA. All patients underwent baseline and 20- to 28-h follow-up perfusion lung scintigraphy. Patients at angiogram centers underwent baseline and 2-h follow-up angiography, while patients at echocardiogram centers underwent baseline, 3-h, and 20- to 28-h echocardiography. Forty-eight patients also participated in an ancillary study of serial fibrinogen and fibrin degradation product levels.
In the first 14 days after randomization, there were six deaths: five (8.3 percent) in the bolus group vs one death (3.7 percent) in the 2-h group (p = 0.66). There were two clinically suspected nonfatal recurrent PEs during the first 14 days after therapy, one in each treatment group. Overall, 14 patients suffered major or other important bleeding: 8 in the bolus group and 6 in the 2-h group (p = 0.35). Changes in efficacy parameters (scans, angiograms, or echocardiograms) were similar in the two treatment groups. After initiation of therapy, patients who had received bolus rt-PA had less depression of fibrinogen levels (p = 0.007) and smaller increases in fibrinogen degradation products (p = 0.013) than patients who had received 100 mg of rt-PA over 2 h.
No significant differences were detected between the bolus rt-PA and 2-h rt-PA with respect to bleeding complications, adverse clinical events, or imaging studies. There was less fibrinogenolysis with the bolus dosing regimen.
检验以下假设:对于血流动力学稳定的肺栓塞(PE)患者,给予较低剂量的静脉推注重组人组织型纤溶酶原激活剂(rt-PA)(0.6mg/kg/15分钟,最大剂量50mg)相比标准的100mg rt-PA在2小时内持续输注,出血并发症会更少。次要目的是比较两种rt-PA给药方案在以下方面的差异:(1)其他不良临床事件的发生率;(2)灌注肺扫描、肺血管造影或超声心动图相对于基线的变化幅度;(3)凝血参数随时间的差异。
双盲、双模拟、随机对照试验。
美国、意大利和加拿大的28家参与研究的医院。
如果患者在就诊后14天内出现PE症状或体征,且肺扫描和/或肺血管造影高度怀疑PE,则可纳入研究。
按2:1的分配比例随机分为接受0.6mg/kg/15分钟(最大剂量50mg)的rt-PA组或100mg/2小时的rt-PA组。90例患者被随机分组,87例患者接受治疗:60例接受静脉推注rt-PA,27例接受2小时持续输注rt-PA。所有患者均进行了基线及20至28小时的随访灌注肺闪烁显像。血管造影中心的患者进行了基线及2小时的随访血管造影,而超声心动图中心的患者进行了基线、3小时以及20至28小时的超声心动图检查。48例患者还参与了纤维蛋白原和纤维蛋白降解产物水平的系列辅助研究。
随机分组后的前14天内,有6例死亡:静脉推注组5例(8.3%),2小时持续输注组1例(3.7%)(p = 0.66)。治疗后的前14天内有2例临床疑似非致命性复发性PE,每个治疗组各1例。总体而言,14例患者发生了严重或其他重要出血:静脉推注组8例,2小时持续输注组6例(p = 0.35)。两个治疗组的疗效参数(扫描、血管造影或超声心动图)变化相似。开始治疗后,接受静脉推注rt-PA的患者纤维蛋白原水平降低幅度较小(p = 0.007),纤维蛋白原降解产物增加幅度较小(p = 0.013),而接受2小时持续输注100mg rt-PA的患者则相反。
在出血并发症、不良临床事件或影像学检查方面,静脉推注rt-PA与2小时持续输注rt-PA之间未检测到显著差异。静脉推注给药方案引起的纤维蛋白溶解较少。