Guinan E C, Molrine D C, Antin J H, Lee M C, Weinstein H J, Sallan S E, Parsons S K, Wheeler C, Gross W, McGarigle C
Department of Pediatric Oncology, Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, Boston, Massachusetts 02115.
Transplantation. 1994 Mar 15;57(5):677-84. doi: 10.1097/00007890-199403150-00009.
Bone marrow transplant patients have impaired responses to pure polysaccharide (PS) vaccines and are at an increased risk for disease caused by PS encapsulated pathogens such as Haemophilus influenzae type B (HIB) and Streptococcus pneumoniae. We immunized 35 BMT patients (21 allogeneic and 14 autologous) ages 2-45 years with pure PS pneumococcal (Pnu-imune 23) HIB-conjugate (HibTITER), and tetanus toxoid vaccines. Patients were assigned to receive vaccines at either 12 and 24 months after transplantation or at 24 months only. Only 19% of all enrolled patients developed protective antibody concentrations (> or = 0.300 microgram antibody nitrogen/ml) to the 6 pneumococcal serotypes measured after the 24-month immunization. Poor response to pneumococcal vaccine was not different for the 2 study groups and was similar to previous studies. In contrast, HIB-conjugate vaccine elicited protective concentrations of antibody (> or = 1.0 microgram/ml) in 56% of patients after 1 dose and in 80% after 2 doses. The group that received 2 doses of HIB-conjugate vaccine had a significantly higher geometric mean antibody concentration of 14.5 micrograms/ml as compared with 1.43 micrograms/ml for those receiving only 1 dose (P = 0.012). Responses to tetanus toxoid vaccine were similar to HIB-conjugate vaccine, with a booster response documented after the second dose. In summary, 2 doses of HIB-conjugate vaccine given at 12 and 24 months after transplantation produced protective antibody concentrations in 80% of patients. While the response to pure PS pneumococcal vaccine was poor, the results with HIB-conjugate vaccine suggest that future pneumococcal conjugate vaccines may also benefit BMT patients.
骨髓移植患者对纯多糖(PS)疫苗的反应受损,并且由PS包膜病原体如B型流感嗜血杆菌(HIB)和肺炎链球菌引起疾病的风险增加。我们对35名年龄在2至45岁的骨髓移植患者(21名同种异体和14名自体)接种了纯PS肺炎球菌(Pnu-imune 23)、HIB结合疫苗(HibTITER)和破伤风类毒素疫苗。患者被分配在移植后12个月和24个月或仅在24个月时接种疫苗。在24个月免疫后测量的所有入组患者中,只有19%对6种肺炎球菌血清型产生了保护性抗体浓度(≥0.300微克抗体氮/毫升)。两个研究组对肺炎球菌疫苗的反应不佳并无差异,且与先前的研究相似。相比之下,HIB结合疫苗在1剂后使56%的患者产生了保护性抗体浓度(≥1.0微克/毫升),2剂后为80%。接受2剂HIB结合疫苗的组的几何平均抗体浓度显著更高,为14.5微克/毫升,而仅接受1剂的组为1.43微克/毫升(P = 0.012)。对破伤风类毒素疫苗的反应与HIB结合疫苗相似,第二剂后有加强反应记录。总之,在移植后12个月和24个月给予2剂HIB结合疫苗使80%的患者产生了保护性抗体浓度。虽然对纯PS肺炎球菌疫苗的反应不佳,但HIB结合疫苗的结果表明,未来的肺炎球菌结合疫苗可能也会使骨髓移植患者受益。