Abe K, Doi K, Katsuragawa S, Yanagisawa T
Department of Radiology, Iwate Medical University.
Nihon Igaku Hoshasen Gakkai Zasshi. 1994 Mar 25;54(4):245-52.
We are developing computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) schemes for chest radiography with which to alert radiologists to possible lesions, and thus potentially improve diagnostic accuracy. Although preliminary results of individual CAD schemes have been encouraging, CAD is still at an early stage of its development. Therefore, we applied our CAD programs in a clinical environment and evaluated its potential usefulness and limitations. CAD programs including automated detection of cardiomegaly, analysis of interstitial infiltrates, and detection of lung nodules were applied to 310 consecutive chest radiographs. CAD results for cardiomegaly and interstitial infiltrates were evaluated subjectively by radiologists and physicists for clinical accuracy and technical problems, respectively, depending on the correspondence of the CAD output to the nature and location of important findings influencing the radiologic diagnosis. CAD results for lung nodules were evaluated objectively by taking into account the number of false positives and true positives. For detection of cardiomegaly, 71% of evaluated cases were judged to be acceptably accurate in terms of clinical accuracy. For analysis of focal and diffuse interstitial infiltrates, 87% and 61% were acceptably accurate, respectively. For detection of lung nodules, 61% were acceptably accurate. More than 70% of CAD output was judged to be possibly accurate in terms of technical aspects. Technical problems were related to failure to detect subtle abnormalities and the occurrence of false positives caused by normal anatomical structures. We believe that CAD has the potential to be a valuable aid for radiologists in clinical practice, if certain technical problems can be overcome and if optimal operating points can be defined for clinical use.
我们正在开发用于胸部X光片的计算机辅助诊断(CAD)方案,以便提醒放射科医生注意可能存在的病变,从而有可能提高诊断准确性。尽管单个CAD方案的初步结果令人鼓舞,但CAD仍处于发展的早期阶段。因此,我们在临床环境中应用了我们的CAD程序,并评估了其潜在的有用性和局限性。包括自动检测心脏肥大、分析间质性浸润和检测肺结节的CAD程序被应用于310张连续的胸部X光片。放射科医生和物理学家分别根据CAD输出与影响放射学诊断的重要发现的性质和位置的对应关系,主观评估心脏肥大和间质性浸润的CAD结果的临床准确性和技术问题。通过考虑假阳性和真阳性的数量,客观评估肺结节的CAD结果。对于心脏肥大的检测,就临床准确性而言,71%的评估病例被判定为准确性可接受。对于局灶性和弥漫性间质性浸润的分析,准确性可接受的分别为87%和61%。对于肺结节的检测,61%的准确性可接受。就技术方面而言,超过70%的CAD输出被判定为可能准确。技术问题与未能检测到细微异常以及正常解剖结构导致的假阳性的出现有关。我们认为,如果某些技术问题能够得到克服,并且能够为临床使用定义最佳操作点,CAD在临床实践中有可能成为放射科医生的有价值的辅助工具。