Tolerance to rat liver allografts. I. Differences between tolerance and rejection are more marked in the B cell compared with the T cell or cytokine response.

Liver allografts in the fully allogenic combination of LEW donor liver to DA recipient (LEW-->DA) are spontaneously tolerated (TOL) with no requirement for immunosuppression, while DA-->LEW allografts are rejected in 12-15 days (REJ). We investigated the mechanism of tolerance induction by identifying differences between TOL and REJ grafts from day 1 to day 9 after transplantation and in normal livers and syngeneic liver graft controls. Infiltrating cell populations were counted after immunohistochemical staining of liver graft sections. There were occasional minor differences between TOL and REJ grafts in the T cell or CD11b/c+ (monocyte/macrophage/granulocyte) infiltrate. In contrast, there was a major difference in B cell infiltrate between TOL and REJ liver grafts. Membrane IgD+ cells were significantly greater in TOL (1796 +/- 225) versus REJ (569 +/- 281) (P = 0.004) portal tracts, as were B220+ cells (1086 +/- 100 vs. 181 +/- 105, P = 0.0004) and CD45RC+ cells (2317 +/- 456 vs. 597 +/- 194, P = 0.004). IgG1, IgG2a, IgM, and IgD deposition in liver allografts, identified by immunohistochemical staining of tissue sections, revealed no IgG or IgD in normal rat liver and low levels of IgM. Deposition of IgG1 was observed in REJ but not in TOL liver on days 7 and 9. IgM was increased in both TOL and REJ liver and appeared to be associated mainly with hepatocytes in REJ and with infiltrate in TOL liver. There was a parallel increase in IgG1-expressing plasma cells in the spleen and lymph nodes of REJ but not TOL animals. Cytokine mRNA was analyzed by reverse transcription and semiquantitative polymerase chain reaction amplification of liver RNA. Increased levels of IL-2, IL-4, IL-6, IL-10, TNF-alpha, transforming growth factor-beta, and IFN-gamma were observed, with similar levels of expression in TOL compared with REJ liver. Cytokine mRNA in syngeneic grafts was not different from normal except for IL-6 and transforming growth factor-beta, which were increased. There is no major difference in the T cell component of the infiltrate or in the extent of upregulation of cytokine mRNA between TOL and REJ grafts. There is a major difference in the B cell compartment, with more B cells in TOL livers and deposition of IgG1 in REJ grafts.