Johnson D L, McCabe M A, Nicholson H S, Joseph A L, Getson P R, Byrne J, Brasseux C, Packer R J, Reaman G
Department of Neurosurgery, Children's National Medical Center, Washington, DC.
J Neurosurg. 1994 Jun;80(6):1004-10. doi: 10.3171/jns.1994.80.6.1004.
The reported success of treatment for children with medulloblastoma must be balanced against the effect that treatment has on the quality of life of long-term survivors. The outcome of long-term survivors reported in previous studies has been conflicting. The authors evaluate the mental and behavioral skills of a group of medulloblastoma survivors from their institution, all of whom had survived for more than 5 years postdiagnosis. A review of the institutional records yielded 32 patients. Twenty-three families were interviewed by telephone and, of these, 13 subjects came to the hospital for detailed neuropsychological and neurological evaluations. Intelligence quotient (IQ) was less than 90 for all participants tested, and patients diagnosed before the age of 3 years had lower IQ scores on average than those diagnosed later. Mean IQ and achievement test scores in reading, spelling, and mathematics were all higher in survivors who had undergone shunting. Achievement test results were often not in accord with intellectual potential, and individual intellectual skills varied widely. Perceptual-motor task performance was below average in more than 50% of the participants, but motor dexterity was more severely affected than perception. Problems in learning and a delay in both physical growth and development were seen in a majority of participants. This study directs attention to the serious difficulties faced by long-term survivors of medulloblastoma and their families, and underscores the importance of routine neuropsychological testing. Moreover, the study provides further impetus to seek alternatives to irradiation in the treatment of malignant brain tumors.
髓母细胞瘤患儿治疗所报道的成功必须与治疗对长期存活者生活质量的影响相权衡。先前研究报道的长期存活者的结果相互矛盾。作者评估了来自他们机构的一组髓母细胞瘤存活者的心理和行为技能,所有这些存活者在确诊后均存活超过5年。查阅机构记录后确定了32例患者。通过电话采访了23个家庭,其中13名受试者前来医院接受详细的神经心理学和神经学评估。所有接受测试的参与者的智商(IQ)均低于90,3岁前确诊的患者平均智商得分低于后来确诊的患者。接受分流术的存活者的平均智商以及阅读、拼写和数学方面的成绩测试分数均更高。成绩测试结果往往与智力潜能不符,而且个体智力技能差异很大。超过50%的参与者的感知运动任务表现低于平均水平,但运动灵活性比感知受到的影响更严重。大多数参与者存在学习问题以及身体生长和发育延迟的情况。这项研究使人们关注髓母细胞瘤长期存活者及其家庭所面临的严重困难,并强调了常规神经心理学测试的重要性。此外,该研究为寻求恶性脑肿瘤治疗中放疗的替代方法提供了进一步的动力。