Lawrence M, Yimer T, O'Dea J K
Save the Children (UK), Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
Eur J Clin Nutr. 1994 Jan;48(1):38-45.
Ethiopian Government guidelines on nutritional survey data and relief provision call for intervention once mean weight-for-length (W/L) in an area falls below 90% of reference, on the basis that mortality is unlikely to rise until this level is reached. In this paper the appropriateness of the 90% cut-off is examined using data from Wolayita, southern Ethiopia. SURVEY DESIGN AND SUBJECTS: Fifteen to 25 villages are selected at random for survey each year, with all children 70-110 cm in length being followed up every 2 months. During the 3 years covered by these analyses 21,701 W/L measurements were made on 5455 children from 65 villages. 126 of the children died.
In the first and third survey years, rapid declines in mean W/L were recorded, with mortality increasing very roughly three-fold (compared to year 2, P < 0.01), even though mean W/L remained at or above 90% of reference at all times. A logistic regression analysis relating mortality to W/L indicates that between 20% and 35% of the greater mortality in years 1 and 3 can be explained by the observed changes in W/L. The remainder occurred because of an increase in underlying or background risk (which might perhaps be expected in the circumstances of generally deteriorating nutritional status).
The results suggest that child mortality is likely to increase before area mean W/L falls to 90% of reference, indicating that emergency interventions should be triggered earlier than at present.
埃塞俄比亚政府关于营养调查数据及救济物资发放的指导方针规定,一旦某地区的身长别体重(W/L)均值降至参考值的90%以下,就需进行干预,理由是在达到这一水平之前死亡率不太可能上升。本文利用埃塞俄比亚南部沃莱塔的数据,对90%这一切点的适宜性进行了研究。
每年随机选取15至25个村庄进行调查,对所有身长在70 - 110厘米的儿童每2个月进行一次随访。在这些分析涵盖的3年中,对来自65个村庄的5455名儿童进行了21701次W/L测量。其中126名儿童死亡。
在第一个和第三个调查年份,记录到W/L均值迅速下降,死亡率大致增加了两倍(与第2年相比,P < 0.01),尽管W/L均值始终保持在参考值的90%及以上。一项将死亡率与W/L相关联的逻辑回归分析表明,第1年和第3年较高死亡率中有20%至35%可由观察到的W/L变化来解释。其余情况是由于潜在或背景风险增加(在营养状况普遍恶化的情况下这或许是可以预料的)。
结果表明,在地区W/L均值降至参考值的90%之前,儿童死亡率可能就会上升,这表明紧急干预应比目前更早启动。