Curtis J R, Patrick D L
Robert Wood Johnson Clinical Scholars Program, University of Washington, Seattle 98105.
Am J Public Health. 1993 Oct;83(10):1425-8. doi: 10.2105/ajph.83.10.1425.
This study summarizes the evidence concerning the association of Black and White race with acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) survival time.
English-language articles measuring survival time with AIDS for Black and White persons were reviewed. Each article was assigned to one of three groups based on the method of subject accrual.
Of the nine eligible studies identified, five studies had inclusive methods of accruing study subjects, and four of these five showed decreased survival time among Black persons. In the studies with more restrictive accrual methods, survival time for Blacks was not decreased.
Although the published studies vary in their results, this variation appears to be systematic according to the method of accruing study subjects. If the accrual method serves to minimize socioeconomic differences between Blacks and Whites, there is no difference in survival time by race. However, if a more inclusive method is used, a significant decrease in AIDS survival time is observed among Blacks. This analysis suggests that, in some studies, race may function as a marker for socioeconomic factors and/or access to health care and that AIDS patients in the lowest socioeconomic or access group have significantly shorter survival times.
本研究总结了有关黑人和白人种族与获得性免疫缺陷综合征(艾滋病)生存时间关联的证据。
对测量黑人和白人艾滋病生存时间的英文文章进行综述。根据受试者纳入方法,每篇文章被归入三组之一。
在确定的9项符合条件的研究中,5项研究采用了包容性的受试者纳入方法,这5项研究中有4项显示黑人的生存时间缩短。在纳入方法更为严格的研究中,黑人的生存时间并未缩短。
尽管已发表的研究结果存在差异,但这种差异似乎根据受试者纳入方法而系统变化。如果纳入方法有助于尽量减少黑人和白人之间的社会经济差异,那么按种族划分的生存时间没有差异。然而,如果使用更具包容性的方法,则观察到黑人艾滋病生存时间显著缩短。该分析表明,在一些研究中,种族可能作为社会经济因素和/或获得医疗保健机会的标志,并且社会经济地位最低或获得医疗保健机会最少的艾滋病患者生存时间明显更短。